BOB DYLAN; FIFTY YEARS ON (2012): The new Vs old Dylans

 |   |  3 min read

Bob Dylan: Duquesne Whistle
BOB DYLAN; FIFTY YEARS ON (2012): The new Vs old Dylans

The new Bob Dylan album Tempest – in yet another uninspiring cover – is released later this week, but already there has been controversy over the first-released song Early Roman Kings on which the croaky old troubadour rides Muddy Waters' famous Mannish Boy riff.

Some have called it a rip-off (which rather damns everyone from Bo Diddley to George Thorogood and beyond who've also used it) and to others it is Dylan with a respectful hat-tip and homage to the great bluesman.

Well, as Dylan himself once observed: Amateurs borrow, professionals steal. And few have had as much stolen from them as Bob Dylan.

Even as early as the mid Sixties – when he was very much alive and creative – new acts were being touted as the “New Dylan”, by which writers meant an artist who had a poetic sensibility, maybe a socio-political “message” and usually an acoustic guitar as the delivery mechanism.

The list of New Dylan's began with Donovan (“Britain's Bob Dylan”) and Barry McGuire (who sang P.F. Sloane's apocalyptic folk ballad Eve of Destruction) and at various times included Loudon Wainwright III, Bruce Springsteen, Patti Smith, Steve Forbert (Dylan with the teeth removed), Steve Earle, Beck . . . Jeez, even Britain's retro-folk-rocking Pete Molinari recently got the tag (although he invited the comparison) and you really had to feel for Jakob Dylan trying to step out from his dad's shadow.

That long shadow falls mostly over Dylan himself however. Tempest is his 35th studio album and arrives half a century after his self-titled debut.

So because he is out there ploughing a field few others explore, Bob Dylan today is mostly just compared to himself. For those who liked folk-protest Bob, newly plugged-in Bob of the mid Sixties, Band-era Bob or even gospel Bob, this means the man faces an impossible task of expectation. So he ignores it and is nothing like any of those Bobs of course, hasn't been for decades.

He is still going to be – and the evidence I've heard of Tempest confirms it – the same cantankerous, gruff-voiced and uncategorisable singer-songwriter who explores the byways of American music in a way no other does.

So Dylan can only be assessed against himself, his recent self. The “Old Dylan” if you will.

It has been like this since his resurrection in the early Nineties after the albums Good As I Been To You and World Gone Wrong. At the time it seemed Dylan had writer's block (both were folk and blues covers) but in retrospect we can see he was, as he had done 30 years previous when he scoured Harry Smith's collection of old folk recorded in the late Twenties and early Thirties, going back to source material to find a voice and invent himself.

Since then, starting with Time Out of Mind in '97 (and ignoring his Christmas album of three years ago), Dylan has been a solitary and singular figure in a musical landscape of his own creation.

Bob_Dylan_TempestHis songs delve into darkness and mythology, offer flashes of wit, slip through timezones so ancient figures walk in our world – the 14 minute title track of his new one refers to both the Titanic and James Cameron's film – and when he sings of love it is about betrayal as much as beauty.

These are timeless themes, yet hardly the stuff of popular music.

And the first single Duquesne Whistle refers to nothing in contemporary music, it is a forward into the past/back to the future song which seems beamed in from the 19th century. But kinda fun. 

And that's where 71-year old Dylan is in the 21st century. He's a man out of time, a lone traveller who won't look back. Yet in many ways Dylan's music is a look back, it's a prowl through the old songbooks of America, through past loves, ancient history and old hurts. And – in Roll On John on Tempest – back to his one-time friend and musical rival John Lennon whose death is subject of the song.

Dylan was once stalked by dangerous fans (doubtless still is), and could have been cut down. Any number of “New Dylan” types might have stepped up to take his place.

Today no one can be called a “New Dylan” because – given the path the “Old Dylan” has carved these past 15 years -- no one else could be.

Share It

Your Comments

Jeffrey Paparoa Holman - Sep 5, 2012

Hi Graham
This post just has to be the best, most balanced and level-headed piece of writing about Dylan now and always that I have seen in many a long day's march.
I like the even-handed way you acknowledge where he has been and seems to be coming from. Also, it's good to see the shallow comments about "stealing" get a a serve.
I am at Iowa re-reading all my influences from the 1970s onwards and some of my early poems, before jumping off somewhere new.
Once guys like Pablo Neruda and Osip Mandelstam are in your head, what's originality, please?
Maybe a very naive and underrated Romantic concept of the unique genius of the individual. Me, I emerge from a tradition - I hope - to which I show respect by mining it deeply, even in my sleep.
Top stuff, cheers, Jeffrey.
GRAHAM REPLIES: Readers might like to know Jeffrey is an excellent writer who has previously contributed to Other Voices Other Rooms and is currently continuing his blog from Iowa:

post a comment

More from this section   Absolute articles index



At age 10, Nathalia Crane was an acclaimed poet and the subject of great controversy, not least for the sexual innuendo of The Janitor’s Boy in which she wrote of lustful feelings and how... > Read more

RUFUS WAINWRIGHT CONSIDERED (2012): Back in the game

RUFUS WAINWRIGHT CONSIDERED (2012): Back in the game

In 2006, Rufus Wainwright presented two concerts at Carnegie Hall in which he recreated the legendary Judy Garland 1961 show in the same venue. The subsequent album was hailed by many critics... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

ONE WE MISSED: Chris Mason-Battley Group/John Psathas; Dialogos (Rattle Jazz)

ONE WE MISSED: Chris Mason-Battley Group/John Psathas; Dialogos (Rattle Jazz)

In 2000, Auckland composer/saxophonist Chris Mason-Battley did something so rare In New Zealand jazz as to be almost unique: for the album Karakia he incorporated and interpreted elements of Maori... > Read more



For many Pink Floyd fans the name of photographer/designer Storm Thorgerson conjures up an image of some Scandinavian psychedelic traveller, hair blowing in the breeze as he traverses landscapes of... > Read more