The Beatles: Carnival of Light, perhaps (1967)

 |   |  1 min read

The Beatles: Carnival of Light, perhaps (1967)

Even more than the 10 minute version of Revolution (below), the most sought-after and obscure Beatles track is the so-far unreleased Carnival of Light, a free-form instrumental which was recorded for a psychedelic event at London's Roundhouse to take place in late January '67.

McCartney said he'd give the organisers a sound effects tape to play and on January 5 the Beatles hunkered down -- perhaps after a smoke -- to create an electronic collage.

When the Anthology rolled around there was some brief consideration given to including it, but the word was that Yoko Ono nixed it, and subsequently Harrison's widow Olivia has apparently insisted George had no interest in it ever being released.

That hasn't stopped McCartney mentioned the possibility of a release whenever he has some new album to flog or there is another Beatles reissue.

The track apparently lasted 13 minutes and 48 seconds and according to Mark Lewisohn in The Complete Recording Sessions (he'd be one of the few who has heard it) the overdubbed four-track tape consists of distorted drum and organ sounds; distorted lead guitar; church organ, various effects (gargling) and screaming, demented voices; and sound effects heavily echoed.

It was at that time the longest thing they had ever recorded, it was labelled Untitled and was very avant-garde (which supports McCartney's long-held contention that he was into avant-garde music before Lennon who presented Revolution 9 for the White Album over a year later).

This track here -- which kicks in after about 10 seconds -- has popped up under the name Carnival of Light and may or may not be very track. It sounds perhaps more like just one or two of the four-track tapes, but interestingly enough in the final minutes it bears considerable resemblance to a section in the McCartney-curated Liverpool Sound Collage, which perhaps adds weight to it being -- if not the actual Carnival of Light -- then at least of the same provenance.

The Beatles, as you've never heard them before? 

Share It

Your Comments

post a comment

More from this section   From the Vaults articles index

Unknown soprano: The Goodness of Chairman Mao is Deeper Than the Sea (1967)

Unknown soprano: The Goodness of Chairman Mao is Deeper Than the Sea (1967)

While there is doubtless some historic or artistic merit in many of tracks posted at From the Vaults, sometimes we pick them just because we can. There may well be artistic merit of some kind in... > Read more

Bob Marley and the Wailers: Let the Lord Be Seen in You (1965)

Bob Marley and the Wailers: Let the Lord Be Seen in You (1965)

Bob Marley only had about seven high-profile years between No Woman No Cry and Redemption Song, about the same length of time the Beatles had between Please Please Me and the break-up. But of... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

Tokyo, Japan: Night cries

Tokyo, Japan: Night cries

The sound of a baby crying in the night is a terrifying thing. The screams go on and on, no one seems to be taking care of it, you look out your window into the darkness but cannot see where the... > Read more

Gil Scott-Heron and Jamie XX: We're New Here (XL)

Gil Scott-Heron and Jamie XX: We're New Here (XL)

Although much hailed -- perhaps because no one expected to hear from him again -- last year's I'm New Here by American poet Gil Scott-Heron did seem a little under-developed: pieces faded out,... > Read more