Dinosaur Jr: I Bet on Sky (Play It Again Sam)

 |   |  <1 min read

Dinosaur Jr: Pierce the Rain
Dinosaur Jr: I Bet on Sky (Play It Again Sam)

The favourable reviews and fan reception for this album -- their third since hatchets were buried and they reformed in 2005 -- have tended to emphasise that there is something comfortable and familiar about Dinosaur Jr here, and that it somewhat downplays the thrilling noise of their first incarnation.

All true. So another way of looking at that might be a disappointing, unchallenging album, perhaps?

In some ways that is also true but maybe you don't come to this trio wanting anything other than the template they invented and were masters of.

So while this one does tick off their familiar stylistic boxes, my money still goes to some of those solo albums by J Mascis (and with The Fog) and Lou Barlow, or of course those albums from their classic period when they were way out on their own and delivering distorted noisy stuff.

You feel a little of those more constrained solo albums seeping in here (Almost Fare which has a whiff of Cobain about it might have come from Mascis' Free So Free) and certainly this sounds more melodic and clean that what they once fired off.

So this won't and hasn't disappointed Dinosaur Jr lifers, but there is a very solid back-catalogue which I'm thinking I'll be returning to more often than this.


Share It

Your Comments

post a comment

More from this section   Music articles index

Jim Noir: Jim Noir (My Dad)

Jim Noir: Jim Noir (My Dad)

Some six months ago the English magazine Q hailed this quirky, poppy and delightfully cheerful album as "the surprise soundtrack of summer 2008" -- which means that for us in the other... > Read more

The Shifting Sands: The Shifting Sands (Fishrider)

The Shifting Sands: The Shifting Sands (Fishrider)

While no one in their right mind would have ever argued the idea of a "Flying Nun/Dunedin sound" other than a few lazy writers back in the day, you'd have to say after even just one quick... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

Dyan's very easy Creamy Mint Potato Salad

Dyan's very easy Creamy Mint Potato Salad

Dyan offers this one (and another salad) for the summer months, and also notes she is an obesity expert! She says "it is a matter of extreme mirth to all my friends & family that I... > Read more

PIANIST JAY McSHANN: From Charlie Parker to Keith Richards . . .

PIANIST JAY McSHANN: From Charlie Parker to Keith Richards . . .

About 20 years ago I interviewed the legendary Kansas City pianist, Jay McShann, in an Auckland bar. He’d flown in late the previous afternoon, had a “talk-rehearsal” with the... > Read more