Tori Amos: Gold Dust (Mercury)

 |   |  <1 min read

Tori Amos: Silent All These Years
Tori Amos: Gold Dust (Mercury)

Having recently tried to read Tori Amos' self-indulgent 2005 book of thoughts and conversations Piece by Piece (is there no goddess or mythological figure she doesn't identify with?), it takes great effort to remain interested in her music, especially for this album where she revisits songs from her 20 year career with Holland's Metropole Orchestra.

But, as with Kate Bush, Amos did redefine the parameters of song and lyric writing so . . .

Yet, however much Amos gilds the liner notes by saying the circumstances brought new images to mind and the notion of “a Memory Box”, this is undeniably little more than an extravagant vanity project from someone who has never undervalued her work or its importance to her audience.

Many songs aren't substantially rethought (just over-augmented by strings and horns) and Amos doesn't take the opportunity (as Joni Mitchell did with the similarly conceived Travelogue) to reinvent them in any meaningfully different way.

Amos' fan base, for whom she has been an important role model as much as a musician, may be happy with this, but with Suzanne Vega currently re-recording her songs and Jeff Lynne doing the same for his Electric Light Orchestra classics you do wonder if “because I could” is such a good reason.

Share It

Your Comments

post a comment

More from this section   Music articles index

George Jones: The Great Lost Hits (Time Life/Southbound)

George Jones: The Great Lost Hits (Time Life/Southbound)

Lawd almighty, but ain't there been some archival albums appearing lately? In the past few weeks Elsewhere has noted albums of Bob Dylan barely out of his teens (here); Kris Kristofferson... > Read more

Various Artists; Where the Boys Are; The Songs of Neil Sedaka and Howard Greenfield (Ace/Border)

Various Artists; Where the Boys Are; The Songs of Neil Sedaka and Howard Greenfield (Ace/Border)

Right at the end of Captain and Tennille's huge pop hit Love Will Keep Us Together in '75-- written by Neil Sedaka and Howard Greenfield -- you can hear Toni Tennille spontaneously weave in the... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

The Feelies: Crazy Rhythms (1980)

The Feelies: Crazy Rhythms (1980)

Pub quiz time and your starter for 10 points: Who was the drummer in Talking Heads? “Okay there was David Byrne and . . . Tina Weymouth on bass and . . . Any of you guys know?”... > Read more

Ornette Coleman, The Shape of Jazz to Come (1959)

Ornette Coleman, The Shape of Jazz to Come (1959)

Recently I was asked if I would contribute a page to a monthly magazine on famous musicians I had met. That part was easy, I've met quite a few. But then the person said they would like to run the... > Read more