Decently and in Order: Necessary surveillance of civilians

 |   |  3 min read

Decently and in Order: Necessary surveillance of civilians

A bill in the government's programme of proposed legislation has already won widespread public support despite drawing fire from civil liberties groups.

The Urban Protocols (And Safety Standards) Bill is intended to make for better living environments and a more polite populace say Labour MPs.

The bill's principal sponsor Phil Ryan (List, Westharbour) says the bill will "make for the smooth running of unregulated urban areas like shopping malls or main thoroughfares where large masses of people are in transit".

"You need only go to Cuba Mall or Queen St to see people walking three-abreast across the footpath blocking the movement of others, mothers dawdling down the middle of the footpath pushing those oversized prams, or groups of teenagers on cellphones conducting their conversations in the centre of a busy thoroughfare. 

"These people have no regard for those who wish to move swiftly and efficiently through streets paid for by the long-suffering tax-payer.

"The problems are exacerbated in enclosed areas such as shopping malls. Over the Christmas period I received numerous calls from disgruntled citizens whose shopping experience at St Luke’s and some other place I'd never heard of had been diminished by the inconsiderate actions of others."

Ryan cited increased incidents of "mall rage" -- up 35 percent according to statistics loosely interpreted from hidden camera footage -- as evidence of the frustration many feel while shopping.

"We have widespread support within the party and already I am hearing from members of Act and National sympathetic to the intent of the legislation."

Labour MPs, encouraged by last year's anti-smoking legislation and recent police crackdowns on drinkers who may be doing their best to get intoxicated, are enthusiastic about the bill which they see as regulating public behaviour for the greater good of all.

"One thinks of yesteryear," says Geraldine Dwight (List, Kakamoana), "and how polite people were."

"We have certainly lost something when it comes to consideration of -- or is that 'for'? -- others. The time has come to legislate in matters of public behaviour."

Dwight intends introducing an amendment allowing for instant fines "for dawdlers, guttersnipes, lollygaggers, the tardy, and the wilfully inconsiderate."

If the bill is passed then other legislation -- fines for women who wait until they get on the bus before taking their purses out, students and especially Asians wearing backpacks on crowded public transport -- is being considered.

"If you are not rude and boorish," says Dwight, "then you have nothing to fear."

Political observers say Labour is riding a wave of middle-New Zealand sentiment driven by baby-boomers reacting against immigrants and younger people, and that the party is playing on fears of declining standards as well as an appeal to people's well-being.

But Howard Hanson of the Civil Liberals Association says recent policing in bars could indicate more repressive legislation to come.

"This was met with extraordinary support, or utter indifference which is much the same thing to a populist politician.

"This crackdown was based on the possibility someone might cause trouble. That should have set alarm bells ringing. But it happened in summer when no one gives a shit, basically."

A leaked memo from within the police seems to confirm Hanson's fears.

It reads in part: "Many members of the public will be, quite rightly, alarmed by these initiatives. Some will argue you cannot intervene just because you think someone may be getting drunk and may have it in mind to possibly commit a crime.

"We need to reiterate -- until they, and we, believe -- that someone who is drunk could well be a victim of a crime, so we are actually saving people from those who might take advantage of them.

"They'll buy that shit."

While there is some unease at the increasing amount of so-called "social legislation" being brought before Parliament -- critics cite the empowering of cinema ushers to arrest patrons who leave wrappers and empty drink containers behind them after a movie -- a recent Colgate-Brunter poll showed 74 percent of the 26.4 people surveyed approved of laws which would get big prams, teenagers with cellphones, and dawdling family groups out of shopping malls and off busy footpaths.

"They're a bloody nuisance and piss me right off," says 54-year old Dave Hummer, a Tauranga developer and Labour supporter. "And if we can also make hip-huggers illegal and bring back School Cert this could be a great country again."

The prime minister, currently overseas, is unavailable for comment.


This first appeared at www.publicaddress.net -- and many people took it seriously. They wrote in with their complaints: slow drivers, lawnmowers before 11am, weed-eaters, people yawning without putting their hand over their mouth, young people in general, old people . . .

Share It

Your Comments

Nick - Oct 28, 2008

ah ...satire!

But seriously, if you're (not you Graham, but everyone, it's a generic 'you' - unless it's et tu Graham?) if you're on the motorway can you please stay in the left hand lane and let the rest of us who are actually wanting to get somewhere in a timely fashion proceed poste haste in what is called 'the fast lane' for a reason.

And if you think that because the speed limit is 100kpmh and you *are* doing 100kmph in the fast lane and therefore I should just chill out, then perhaps you could pull over to the shoulder and we could discuss it. With our fists. Unless you are bigger than me (likely), in which case I'll just drive off.

post a comment

More from this section   Something articles index

The Power of Speech: a short story

The Power of Speech: a short story

I recently spent a rather distressing luncheon engagement with a moderately well-known author. Aside from hearing much invaluable gossip about better known writers than my friend, I was also... > Read more

HISTORY ACTUALLY REPEATS (2014): Rare, lost or out-of-print New Zealand music gets a second coming

HISTORY ACTUALLY REPEATS (2014): Rare, lost or out-of-print New Zealand music gets a second coming

This week I was invited to a function in Auckland hosted by recordedmusic.co.nz. The event -- at which Shona Laing and John Hanlon performed -- was entitled Tied to the Tracks, named after a... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

Berlin: Another brick in the Wall

Berlin: Another brick in the Wall

The first thing you see when you come out of the Bernauerstrasse underground station in Berlin is the ruin: no houses down one side of the road, just overgrown and scrappy wasteland spotted with... > Read more

Moby Grape, Moby Grape (1967)

Moby Grape, Moby Grape (1967)

The short and dramatic story of San Francisco psychedelic folk-rockers Moby Grape is one of the collision of blazing musical talent, shonky management, record company overkill and bad luck. And it... > Read more