Public Service Broadcasting: Every Valley (PIAS)

 |   |  2 min read

People Will Always Need Coal
Public Service Broadcasting: Every Valley (PIAS)

The two previous albums by Britain's boffinish PSB – Inform-Educate- Entertain and The Race for Space – had an audience outreach in their sampled themes: voices from the past evoking speed, progress, science, energy and vigour propelling us into the future . . .

Couple those themes with energetic music borne out of techno, rock, pop and dance, and the albums were very hard to resist. Their videos and live presentation with archival clips just added extra allure, lustre and another dimension.

For many however, this one is going to be harder to connect with because it is about something as unfashionable and politically problematic as coal mining, specifically in Wales.

As an American friend recently noted about President Trump's drive to re-open coal mines in the States: “These people actually want to go down mines in the 21st century? How desperate must they be?”

No, there's very little glamour in a subterranean life fraught with collapses and fires, death in the darkness or black lung disease which had middle-aged men coughing up blood in their dirt poor homes while huddled around the fire and their kids looked on knowing this might be their fate too.

To most people, coal mining is an archaic and inhumane way of life, something very hard to get romantic about or nostalgic for.

But PSB are canny enough to know this, and so take an interesting skew. Not into the bleak lives of miners, but into an almost heroic and stoic world where men did what others wouldn't.

It opens by addressing the low regard in which they were held but also their assured arrogance (the deliberately grandiloquent title track at the start with a sample from Richard Burton's rumblingly poetic and Welsh baritone and unrolls like a cinematic opening sequence about “the kings of the underworld”).

Then there is the aural descent in the cage, down to the pit and possible sudden death.

But here too is the sense of certainty (“the foundation of the future”, “enough [coal] for another 400 years”, “a secure future”) which the industry gave these beleaguered communities in an appalling century which began with two world wars punctuated by the Great Depression.

And then the smashing of the industry and workforce under Margaret Thatcher and her Tory party's iron fist (on the guitar-thrash punk fury of All Out and a voice which says “we went on strike for a job”).

This story arc is welded together by PSB's assured sense of driving rhythms, ear-worm melodies (Progress with Tracyanne Campbell's soulful vocals), the humanity at the heart of the story (You + Me with guest vocalist Lisa Jen Brown from Wales' 9Bach) and more . . .

On the face of it, Every Valley might be a much tougher call than its predecessors, but where those previous albums spoke of great projects of science and progress, this one moves more towards the intimate and human story of people in small villages and towns who worked in unthinkably awful conditions only to be marginalised by a society which once depended on them for light and heat.

When the sun sets on the final track Take Me Home with a proud Welsh male choir you can understand why this subject drew in Public Service Broadcasting: It's not about the distant past but about the uncertainties and travails of the present day.

The past is ever-present.

Elsewhere has archival interviews with PSB's J Willgoose here

Share It

Your Comments

Keith Shackleton - Aug 16, 2017

Struck a chord with a lot of people in the UK. Quite hard to get because it was sold out in a few record shops I went in over there in the past month. GRAHAM REPLIES: One of those albums that obliges people to suspend judgement on the issue of coal mining which they might disapprove of and simply engage with the history and the humanity perhaps?

post a comment

More from this section   Music articles index

Travis & Fripp: Thread (Southbound)

Travis & Fripp: Thread (Southbound)

By coincidence this disc turned up as I was reading David Sheppard's fascinating (if fruitily written) biography of Brian Eno, On Some Faraway Beach.I was at the chapters about his work with... > Read more

Greg Fleming: Working Poor Country (all main digital platforms)

Greg Fleming: Working Poor Country (all main digital platforms)

In a recent Facebook conversation I instigated, I questioned how little political comment there has been in New Zealand popular music. As expected, many people weighed in with particular songs .... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

GOODFELLAS, a film by MARTIN SCORSESE: Making a killing in crime

GOODFELLAS, a film by MARTIN SCORSESE: Making a killing in crime

Within the ever-expanding genre of gangster flicks - from 1931 and James Cagney's Irish hood in Little Caesar to the quiet menace of Tony Soprano - there could never be consensus about the best... > Read more

Edinburgh, Scotland: Lauriston Castle and New Orleans

Edinburgh, Scotland: Lauriston Castle and New Orleans

Although separated by culture and the vast Atlantic Ocean, there is a curious link between the multi-cultural, musical city of New Orleans and an antique-filled castle in a leafy suburb of... > Read more