THE TEMPTATIONS: Creating Heaven for Motown right here on Earth

 |   |  1 min read

The Temptations: Papa Was A Rolling Stone
THE TEMPTATIONS: Creating Heaven for Motown right here on Earth

The ever-changing line-up of the legendary Motown soul group the Temptations (only two original members of the '61 founding group by the mid-Nineties when the five-disc retrospective Emperors of Soul was released) made their career a little difficult to follow.

But they were one of the cornerstone acts on Motown.

Even their most ardent fans might have thought the Emperors of Soul collection just a bit too much of their special magic to be readily assimilated, but it was a fair tribute to a band which, according to Dave Marsh' The Heart of Rock and Soul, spun almost a dozen of the greatest singles of all time (not to mention album tracks), among them My Girl, Since I've Lost My Baby and Don't Look Back, all in '65 and all written and produced for them by Smokey Robinson.

That was quite a way to start a chart-worrying career.

The box set opens with the endearingly lo-fi Come On (and the terrific Romance Without Finance which was the flipside of the '61 Oh Mother single) and then charges through that ever-expanding catalogue of hits: My Girl, Ain't Too Proud to Beg and Just My Imagination (both later covered by the Stones), the exceptional Papa Was A Rolling Stone of '72 (written by Norman Whitfield who also wrote, along many other hits, War for Edwin Starr), I Wish It Would Rain . . .

With great songwriters on hand, the famous and fantastic Funk Brothers backing them in the studio, frontmen such as David Ruffin ('64-'68), Melvin Franklin ('60-'95) and Eddie Kendricks ('60-'71) as well as a revolving door of great harmony singers (some of whom would occasionally handle frontline duties), the Temptations could adapt their approach to any material.

As with many acts on Motown, they weren't immune to what was going on in the streets and homes of black America: Papa Was A Rolling Stone was an early, if slightly ambivalent, look at absentee black fathers (he was a jerk but we sure miss him).

Mostly however they were a band which specialised in love songs, but as the times got tougher in the Seventies and the membership kept pulling apart, the Temptations ceased to be the hit-factory they once were. They moved to Atlantic Records but again their former success wasn't to be repeated. In 1980 they re-signed with Motown and although their Reunion album was well received their best days were long behind them.

Various members came and went throughout the Nineties and they quit Motown again in 2004. There is a Temptations group (and various splinter groups) even now -- but the Temptations who made the great music was that which lasted -- on record at least -- between the early Sixties and the mid-Seventies.

Few groups could match them song-for-song. Emperors of soul indeed. 

Share It

Your Comments

post a comment

More from this section   Absolute articles index

THE BEST OF ELSEWHERE (2019): THE YEAR IN REISSUES

THE BEST OF ELSEWHERE (2019): THE YEAR IN REISSUES

Round the Elsewhere way we used to joke that there's a reason people want to live in the past: It was cheaper back then. That's no longer true if in your listening habits you allow the past... > Read more

BENNY SOEBARDJA PROFILED (2012): The godfather of the Indonesian prog-rock underground

BENNY SOEBARDJA PROFILED (2012): The godfather of the Indonesian prog-rock underground

Even today with better access to information, the excavation of musical vaults around the globe and the acceptance of world music, it still seems to come as a surprise to many that countries such... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

THE BARGAIN BUY: Dave Dobbyn; Original Album Classics

THE BARGAIN BUY: Dave Dobbyn; Original Album Classics

A curious thing happened recently when -- in separate incidents -- I spoke with some young people and then others my own age and the subject of Dave Dobbyn's long career came up. Both groups... > Read more

THE BARGAIN BUY: Aerosmith; Toys in the Attic (Sony)

THE BARGAIN BUY: Aerosmith; Toys in the Attic (Sony)

There's a fairly lazy shorthand about Aerosmith, they are the band that so wanted to be the Rolling Stones that over time frontman Steve Tyler and guitarist Joe Perry started to look like Mick and... > Read more