THE BARGAIN BUY: Percy Sledge; When a Man Loves a Woman

 |   |  1 min read

Percy Sledge: When She Touches Me
THE BARGAIN BUY: Percy Sledge; When a Man Loves a Woman

In his 1989 book The Heart of Rock and Soul; The 1001 Greatest Singles Ever Made, the American writer Dave Marsh has the title track of this album in at #31.

That's more than 100 places higher than Born in the USA, My Generation and the Sex Pistols' God Save the Queen.

Yes, it is that good.

As Marsh notes, it is "barely a record at all. It's just a guy singing his song, sparely accompanied by a rhythm section . . .".

Yet out of such simplicity is genius wrought because Percy Sledge pours his heart and soul into the lyric which is more than just a song about love, but what love can do.

"Lovin' eyes can never see" he sings towards the end, and that encapsulates the idea that not only is love blind but -- coupled with the passing lyrics about having been played for a fool -- the singer himself is the victim of a love betrayed.

Released in mid '66, When a Man Loves a Woman has become a soul staple ever since, but you'd be hard pushed to find a better version than Sledge's aching original.

The greatness of that song has meant it has lent its title to a few knocked-off Sledge (and others') collections, but it is best heard in the context of this, the original album.

Sledge could reach into those deeply hurting areas of the heart and he does it again here on When She Touches Me (Nothing Else Matters) in which he is prepared to put up with the pains and betrayals just for that loving touch: "I should leave her . . . but when she touches me . . ."

He also swings through the great You're Pouring Water on a Drowning Man and You Fooled Me -- other hurtin' heart songs about lies and deception -- but he remains the optimist (Love Makes the World Go Round) because "when a man loves a woman . . . "

Although, after Success ("to me success is being' loved by you") the album ends with Love Me Like You Mean It.

Few artists could channel Southern soul like Percy Sledge.

JB_logoAnd this essential album is just $10 at JB Hi-Fi stores here in a Japanese import edition which has a replica of the original cover and liner notes, plus lyrics (in English).

One of the great soul singers here captured at a peak. And that makes the album this week's recommended Bargain Buy

Share It

Your Comments

post a comment

More from this section   The Bargain Buy articles index

THE BARGAIN BUY: Thin Lizzy; Classic Album Selection (Universal)

THE BARGAIN BUY: Thin Lizzy; Classic Album Selection (Universal)

Some think the only essential Thin Lizzy album is Live and Dangerous from 1978. Agreed in a way but . . . only three quarters of a brilliant live album, as we shall see. This six... > Read more

THE BARGAIN BUY: The Original Album Series; Tommy James and the Shondells

THE BARGAIN BUY: The Original Album Series; Tommy James and the Shondells

One of the best, most revealing and somewhat scary books about the inside story of the American pop music business in the money-no-go-round Sixties came from Tommy James, the man who scored hit... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

Odetta: A legend ignored

Odetta: A legend ignored

To be honest, I had largely forgotten about Odetta until she died in 2008 at the age of 77. I imagined her as much older actually as she seemed to have been around since Biblical times, or at least... > Read more

STONED by ANDREW LOOG OLDHAM: Would you let your daughter meet Andrew?

STONED by ANDREW LOOG OLDHAM: Would you let your daughter meet Andrew?

Andrew Loog Oldham enjoyed considerable notoriety in the early Sixties as the young manager/producer of the Rolling Stones. He hit the headlines in his own right for his liner notes to a Stones LP... > Read more