MAN OF ARAN by ROBERT J FLAHERTY/BRITISH SEA POWER (DVD/CD): The lonely sea and the sky

 |   |  2 min read

British Sea Power: No Man is an Archipelago (from The Man of Aran)
MAN OF ARAN by ROBERT J FLAHERTY/BRITISH SEA POWER (DVD/CD): The lonely sea and the sky

American film-maker Robert J Flaherty (1884-1951) from Michigan was a man who liked to explore lives on the edges of his known world: he went to Inuit territory to film his pseudo-doco Nanook of the North of 1922 (which, along with actor Anthony Quinn, allegedly inspired Bob Dylan’s Quinn the Eskimo); Samoa for Moana four years later (Flaherty also co-wrote Tabu with F.W. Murnau in ’31, another South Seas drama) and to Cajun country for Louisiana Story in 1948.

These pseudo-docos -- he would impose a storyline on the footage and ask people to re-enact events against the backdrop of their world -- were enormously popular in their day as they appeared to show Man against the Elements and the indifference of Nature. They were the National Geographic of the silver screen and even today their black’n’white doco quality is quite compelling.flaloius

For Man of Aran in’34, Flaherty went to the sea-battered and windswept islands of Aran off the west coast of Ireland where small communities eked out a living from fishing and survived by growing potatoes in seaweed on these barren but dramatic rocky outcrops where there is no soil.

Aran, frankly, looks like a bloody awful place and Flaherty’s docu-drama pits the locals against the crashing sea, the howling wind, the stark rock and the glowering sky which often fills the top two thirds of the screen. Figures in black silhouette walk intrepidly beneath huge thunderheads and through spray-swept landscapes.

As in his other films Flaherty imposes a narrative on the footage and asked these hardly locals to hunt basking sharks using hand-held harpoons (they hadn’t done this in decades) in a boat no longer than these massive creatures.

This is high drama but in its quasi-social realism also has an epic quality which these days looks faintly absurd (although Flaherty mostly avoided close-ups of heroic and determined jut-jaw faces that was the hallmark of Soviet social-realism).

Yet the relentless power of the sea, the sheer cliffs which drop hundreds of meters into the roiling ocean which is white with surf and spray, and the hardiness of the folk (not to mention their slightly strange attire of large tams, and billowing skirts on the women) makes for fascinating viewing.

aranThe original 76 minute film has been released on DVD with a contemporary soundtrack added by the appropriately named indie-rock band British Sea Power who now provide a dramatic, largely instrumental accompaniment (guiatrs, piano, cello etc) which similarly evokes space, dark clouds gathering and huge swells of sound to mirror Flaherty’s memorable images.

The film comes with a stand alone CD of the music (which should appeal to fans of Explosions in the Sky, Joy Division, early Cure etc) but it is the beautifully film and music combination on the DVD which is the attraction. 

Flaherty’s Man of Aran may be a triumph of artifice and art over realism, but it is still a moving (and occasionally unintentionally amusing) film.

Share It

Your Comments

David Trubridge - Oct 3, 2012

What do you mean "bloody awful place"? It is bloody amazing! Watch the episode of Coast about it or read 'The Stones of Aran' or any of the many other books written by people drawn there. Better still go there . . ! GRAHAM REPLIES: I actually said "looks like a bloody awful place". Barren, remote, windswept, cold, people living off potatoes and fish . . . It does, to me, look like a bloody awful place. Would I go there? Of course. Would I want to live there. Well, despite the dramatic geography . . .

post a comment

More from this section   Film articles index

APOLLO 11, a doco by TODD DOUGLAS MILLER (2019): Close enough to touch . . .

APOLLO 11, a doco by TODD DOUGLAS MILLER (2019): Close enough to touch . . .

Even in the too-near future when fancy rockets from President Trump's visionary Space Force are shuttling Russian oligarchs and wealthy white billionaires off to the safety of Mars as the polluted... > Read more

THE EYES OF ORSON WELLES, a doco by MARK COUSINS

THE EYES OF ORSON WELLES, a doco by MARK COUSINS

Many decades ago when taking a class in film analysis to a group of enthusiastic young people, I was at a loss as to how introduce Orson Welles, his art and work was so diverse and massive. By... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

Miami Beach, Florida: The goofy gunman

Miami Beach, Florida: The goofy gunman

In the fuzzy Polaroid I am standing next to a short, goofy-looking guy with a curly blond Afro. He is holding a multicoloured cocktail. And I have a parrot on my head. It was at a travel... > Read more

THE FAMOUS ELSEWHERE QUESTIONNAIRE: Gary Harvey

THE FAMOUS ELSEWHERE QUESTIONNAIRE: Gary Harvey

Gary Harvey is one of New Zealand's great journeyman rock'n'roll blues musicians. He has been long overdue for the questionnaire (let alone a decent paycheque for his labours over the years) and... > Read more