FIVE MINUTES OF HEAVEN, a film by OLIVER HIRSCHBIEGEL (Madman DVD)

 |   |  1 min read

FIVE MINUTES OF HEAVEN, a film by OLIVER HIRSCHBIEGEL (Madman DVD)

Although this seems to have all the hallmarks of a stage play adapted for the screen, Five Minutes to Heaven (by the director of the gripping Hitler-bunker drama Downfalll) is based on a true story which never exactly happened.

The truth at the core is that a young, angry teenager out to prove himself to the local Ulster Volunteer Force murders, in cold blood, a young Catholic boy during the Troiubles of the mid Seventies.

He is seen carrying out the killing by the victim's younger brother and (as we later learn) is subsequently caught and imprisoned.

That however is just the preamble to the adult encounter -- for a television programme -- of the two men: the young Protestant now grown into a man who makes his living telling his story and attempting reconciliation (Liam Neeson), and the boy Joe (James Nesbitt) still embittered and a victim of the crime.

Neeson as Alistair Little is persuasive as a man still living with his past and trying in his own way to make amends, but the film belongs to the emotionally volatile and unpredicatable Joe who has been brutalised and blamed by his family for doing nothing to save his older brother. He is emotionally crippled by self-loathing and rage behind the black humour he exhibits.

Much of the story is true -- the tragic events of the Seventies, the subsequent lives of the characters -- but in reality they never met as this film plays out.

The story arc appears to move to a climax but more than once sidesteps and the result is a drama which pulls rather too many punches. It is left to the direct-to-camera device of Little being the filmmaker's mouthpiece in identifying the need to stop the indoctrination of angry and rootlesss young men (be they Irish or Muslim) with poisonous ideolgies.

So while worthy, at times compelling and even powerful in places, the staged encounter and the blunt-edge message undermine what might have been an even more commanding and important film.

Share It

Your Comments

post a comment

More from this section   Film articles index

HOOKED: ANTI-DRUG FILMS FROM THE 30'S TO THE 70'S (Rocket/Triton DVD): Marijuana to murder in 15 minutes

HOOKED: ANTI-DRUG FILMS FROM THE 30'S TO THE 70'S (Rocket/Triton DVD): Marijuana to murder in 15 minutes

Every generation thinks it invents the same two things: swearing and sex. Equally, in the Western world at least, for the past century or so every generation gets the soundtrack it needs. And the... > Read more

HARRY SINCLAIR INTERVIEWED (2011): Expat filmmaker talks about his life

HARRY SINCLAIR INTERVIEWED (2011): Expat filmmaker talks about his life

Harry Sinclair who has lived in the States for the past 10 years – the last four in LA, years prior to that in New York – is still well known in New Zealand. His reputation rests on... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

Denniston, West Coast, New Zealand: Damned and damp

Denniston, West Coast, New Zealand: Damned and damp

The weather was perfect: fiercely cold, low mist and a chilling drizzle. This is ideal when you are at Denniston, because only in such miserable conditions can you get some small appreciation of... > Read more

THE SIXTIES by JENNY DISKI: What a long strange trip . . .

THE SIXTIES by JENNY DISKI: What a long strange trip . . .

Has any decade been more feted, essayed and mythologised than the Sixties? The flowers in hippies’ headbands had barely wilted when the analysis began, and since then many of those who were... > Read more