Theo Bleckmann: Elegy (ECM/Ode)

 |   |  1 min read

Comedy Tonight
Theo Bleckmann: Elegy (ECM/Ode)

Every now and again we allow ourselves to say, “an acquired taste” . . .

But usually that means something totally difficult and out there on the perimeter . . . like Yoko Ono and Pere Ubu used to be.

But, to these ears, this album by singer/poet Bleckmann and a very decent jazz quarter is what a university music department might call “Art Music”.

Which means not just mainstream classical stuff but music which is, in this writer's opinion, indulgent and self-important.

As here on this album of spare words (and blamelessly supportive musicianship) which would have you believe this has greater intellectual and emotional import than it conveys.

At times singer Bleckmann – who relies heavily on the quartet to bridge the divide between meaning and vocalisation – attempts to forge the bond between Stephen Sondheim (Comedy Tonight) and Zen (Beckman's own Fields, a poem by Zhiao Zhan).

There are rare songs here – the centrepiece To Be Shown To Monks At A Certain Temple written by Zhiao Zhan around 760AD – which work across that chasm.

Aside from when the acoustic quartet take small possession (the two minute Cortege for example) this to these ears this is . . . .

Well, to paraphrase Macbeth: “Now pretension hath made its masterpiece”.

Bleckmann's quasi-pop tune Take My Life – despite guitarist Ben Monder and the band getting a chance to dig deep in the singer's absence – comes halh an hour in and far too late to redeem this.

I shall await the consideration of graduate student's thesis to tell me why I should be engaged by this.

Decent band though.

“Now condescension hath made its masterpiece”?

Share It

Your Comments

post a comment

More from this section   Jazz at Elsewhere articles index

Julia Hulsmann Trio: Sooner And Later (ECM/Ode)

Julia Hulsmann Trio: Sooner And Later (ECM/Ode)

It has been almost a decade since German pianist Hulsmann’s trio impressed mightily with the emotionally still and evocative The End of A Summer, but also about six since we found her... > Read more

Trio Antipodes: Upside Downwards (MAPL/Rattle)

Trio Antipodes: Upside Downwards (MAPL/Rattle)

Interesting band name and title on this album by a jazz trio out of Canada. Interesting because the guitarist/composer in this bass-less line-up – guitar, piano and... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

THE FAMOUS ELSEWHERE WRITERS QUESTIONNAIRE: Peter Wells

THE FAMOUS ELSEWHERE WRITERS QUESTIONNAIRE: Peter Wells

New Zealand novelist, historian and film-maker Peter Wells says he was a timid boy at school but thanks the bullies because they forced him to put down on paper what he couldn't say aloud.... > Read more

Selwyn Birchwood: Living in a Burning House (Alligator/Southbound)

Selwyn Birchwood: Living in a Burning House (Alligator/Southbound)

This 35-year old bluesman from Florida sounds much older than his years, and although on Chicago's tough urban-blues Alligator label (which makes sense) at times his brutal guitar playing could... > Read more