Peter Brotzmann; Silo Park, Auckland. May 3, 2014

 |   |  4 min read

Peter Brotzmann; Silo Park, Auckland. May 3, 2014

There were a couple of key junction points where jazz parted company with its broad audience. The first came when it uncoupled itself from dance music in the post-war period and by the Fifties had become a serious, listening art form.

The second occurred when – a decade later – musicians extended the jazz contract into what became the politicised “free jazz”.

That kind of improvised music has become, in the words of Spinal Tap's manager Ian Faith, more selective about its audience.

A further wedge was driven in hard by the champions of this free jazz art form who became almost evangelical in promoting its difficulties as though only enlightenment can come through hardship.

Brotzmann___Silo__4_That kind of weird, almost pursed-lip Presbyterian ideology among free jazz cheerleaders also smacked of the moral superiority of difficult music.

The message seemed to be, if it's uncomfortable it must be good for you.

Well, no music of any form confers moral superiority, not even religious music.

If it did there'd be no priests standing with their heads hung in shame in the docks, and well-heeled business patrons of opera would all ascend to Heaven and sit on the right hand of God.

Free jazz – call it just improvised music if you will – simply is what it is, it contains its own rewards and difficulties . . . and the great German saxophonist Peter Brotzmann, last seen in New Zealand in 1987, delivered both in this extraordinary solo performance.

Brotzmann___Silo__5_The venue – the old silo towers at the western end of the redeveloped Silo Park – was both ideal and inadequate: Ideal because the impossibly tall octagonal room allowed for the music to hang in the still air and echo on itself; inadequate because the small space meant many were relegated to standing outside the arches and could quite get the full benefit of that experience.

But Brotzmann – who played four extended improvisations, only announcing the final one in a barely audible voice – pulled an interesting cross-section of people which, and this is unusual at any concert let alone one like this, reached right across the demographics. 

Brotzmann___Silo__17_What they were treated to was a tour-de-force of solo saxophone by a man who has more than five decade of experience to draw on.

About a third the way in during his 40 minute opening piece something occurred to me about this visceral, discordant, often beautiful and always compelling playing. That while many people who like their perhaps narrow idea of jazz would find it difficult, it makes perfectly good sense to those of us who grew up accepting Jimi Hendrix, a man who could – in the middle of howling feedback – channel the most sublime melodies.

Like Hendrix – and coincidentally both Hendrix and Brotzmann had cornerstone music entitled Machine Gun just a few years apart at the end of the volatile Sixties – Brotzmann finds beauty in pure noise, and runs parallel musical ideas which can be drawn in separate directions depending on which appeals in the moment.

Brotzmann___Silo__11_Brotzmann's tonal reach goes from a sound like a dark didgerdoo up to notes which can probably only be heard by nearby dogs. He makes anguished cries and ineffably sad pleas of romanticism, sometimes simultaneously.

At one point during that first piece I imagined this must be the sound a mad woman makes when she throws her shit at the walls of her padded cell, and yet within minutes I could swear the spirit of Lester Young was in the room.

Brotzmann___Silo__9_This was not difficult listening at all.

In fact it was noticeable that many in the small space closed their eyes and immersed themselves in the moment as the music took them away, and others often – as I did – looked up into that high space above as if to see where the notes had gone.

But had they all disappeared, hanging for moment then evaporating into the air.

Brotzmann___Silo__13_Jazz/improvised music is a music of being in the moment, it exists best when played and experienced live, it responds to the situation and – especially in this case – to the sonic possibilities of the given space.

Brotzmann's music – immediate, constantly changing shape, unfettered and unmediated, spoken from brain to finger in an instant – is impossible to describe . . . but is unforgettable when experienced live.

An extraordinary night.

There is an interview with Peter Brotzmann here

Images here by Garry Brandon who has been a concert and commercial photographer for decades in New Zealand. All images copyright Garry Brandon, whose website of archival concert and other work is here.



Share It

Your Comments

Graham Donlon - May 6, 2014

A good piece! Enjoyed reading it, wish I'd been there!

Doug Newdick - May 10, 2014

A very thoughtful review, especially that comparison with Hendrix. I saw him play at Wellington, and enjoyed it thoroughly. It didn't seem to be as bruising as his ensemble pieces from the past (I've got several Last Exit albums, and have heard the mighty "Machinegun"), though was still noisier than many traditional jazz listeners would have expected I think. There were great quieter, and tender moments. Here is a man who really loves his instrument, intent on getting the most out of it. Thanks very much Graham for letting me know this was on.

post a comment

More from this section   Live reviews + concert photos articles index

MARLON WILLIAMS, REVIEWED (2021): Music, art, performance and quiet drama

MARLON WILLIAMS, REVIEWED (2021): Music, art, performance and quiet drama

Some New Zealand artists have understood the power and importance of presentation when it comes to a show – Split Enz being the most obvious – while others simply get on stage in what... > Read more

Let It Be; A Beatles Celebration, Civic Theatre, Auckland, March 26 2015

Let It Be; A Beatles Celebration, Civic Theatre, Auckland, March 26 2015

There's a very simple answer to the question of why people go to tribute shows. They go to hear the familiar music . . . and to check out how well the performers... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

The Jimi Hendrix Experience: Electric Ladyland (1968)

The Jimi Hendrix Experience: Electric Ladyland (1968)

There's a very good case to be made that The Jimi Hendrix Experience album of 1967 was the most accomplished and innovative debut of the rock era. (Indeed I hope I made the case for Are You... > Read more

Youssou N'Dour: Dakar-Kingston (Universal)

Youssou N'Dour: Dakar-Kingston (Universal)

After decades of almost becoming the biggest star out of Africa and commanding a global audience (support from Peter Gabriel, the 7 Seconds single with Neneh Cherry, Mandela concerts and so on)... > Read more