BEST OF ELSEWHERE 2007 Arcade Fire: Neon Bible (EMI)

 |   |  1 min read

Arcade Fire: Keep The Car Running
 BEST OF ELSEWHERE 2007 Arcade Fire: Neon Bible (EMI)

Yes, after the towering success of their debut album Funeral, you will be reading any number of reviews of this lavishly orchestrated, dramatic follow-up by this big Montreal-based ensemble.

Let me be the first to say then that there are as many resonances of Echo and the Bunnymen/Teardrop Explodes here as there are of stadium-shaped Springsteen.

Like the Killers' second album, this seems purpose-built for huge shows (check the dramatic pipe organ opener on Intervention and tell me that won't sound thrilling wafting across a packed field and terraces), and singer Will Butler pulls out every dramatic flourish in the manner of Bono at his most messianic.

They also roped in Calexico's horn players, and recorded a military choir in Budapest.

My guess is that after making that debut for what they assumed to be a small audience then getting swept from small halls to stadiums by its success they have, again like the Killers, written with that atmosphere and audience in mind.

It is an oddly produced thing however, some tracks leap out and others sound way back and murky.

My pick is this: reviewers will be divided.* Some will hear it as pompous, pretentious and over-orchestrated; others will just get swept up in the overwrought drama and air-punching choruses.

It must be the kid in me, because although I accept all of the former I'm erring toward the latter. Sounds fantastic turned up VERY loud.

 

*As it happened I was both wrong, and right. Critics widely acclaimed the album which meant I was wrong, but was sort of right in my assessment of the album.

Share It

Your Comments

Martin - May 10, 2009

Arcade Fire's Neon Bible was met with a mostly universal seal of praise.I was riveted with their grand display.I only read one disparate review,he felt Butler moaned without pause.If Butler was unhappy cause the planes keep crashing always two by two and he don't wanna see when the planes hit the ground .Seems a normal decent reaction to me and relevant to global concern.Working in a building downtown in any large American city is unpopular.Butlers high intellect alongside the flamboyant colour and excessive talent of the band put Neon Bible in the top 5 of '07.As for the earlier mentioned ,no mates reviewer ,pull yourself together.

post a comment

More from this section   Music articles index

The Clean: Mashed (Arch Hill)

The Clean: Mashed (Arch Hill)

What can you say? The Clean recorded live during their '07 national tour.Really, enough said: David Kilgour's guitar just gets more mercurial and expressive over time (if sometimes pulling back... > Read more

Lee Hazlewood: A House Safe for Tigers (Light in the Attic/Southbound)

Lee Hazlewood: A House Safe for Tigers (Light in the Attic/Southbound)

Following the release of the collection The LHI Years; Singles, Nudes and Backsides, comes this reissue of a film soundtrack, a film which by every account was pretty bizarre. Filmed on the... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

GUEST WRITER ROB SCOTT on the tug of two homelands

GUEST WRITER ROB SCOTT on the tug of two homelands



It really sneaks up on you, New Zealand. 

I’ve travelled close to 30 hours to get here. On this final 4 hour leg, I watch a few M*A*S*H episodes as the expanse of ocean... > Read more

Harry Nilsson, Nilsson Schmilsson (1971)

Harry Nilsson, Nilsson Schmilsson (1971)

The too-short life of the greatly under-appreciated singer/songwriter Harry Nilsson (1941-94) was full of bitter ironies: not the least was that this gifted songwriter's biggest hits were written... > Read more