Various: While My Guitar Gently Weeps (Universal)

 |   |  <1 min read

Doobie Brothers: Long Train Running
Various: While My Guitar Gently Weeps (Universal)

There's a lot wrong with this double disc compilation: the title track is from the late Jeff Healy not by its author George Harrison; Thin Lizzy's Still in Love With You is the studio version rather than the far superior live one; you get soft-rockers Bread (Guitar Man) and Matthews' Southern Comfort (Woodstock) jammed between Fleetwood Mac's Black Magic Woman and Peter Frampton's live Show Me The Way; there are some songs you never thought of as having guitar to the fore (Stealers Wheel's Dylanesque Stuck in the Middle With You) and if I never heard Daddy Cool's Eagle Rock again I'd die happy.

All that said, what is right about it then?

Well it is a damn fine collection for the car because you get to bellow along with Lynyrd Skynyrd (Sweet Home Alabama), get world weary for Creedence's Have You Ever Seen the Rain, thump the steeling wheel on the Doobies' Long Train Running, laugh along with Joe Walsh's classic Life's Been Good (where he reveals observations on fame worthy of Randy Newman, but to a better tune) and turn up the volume for Roy Buchanan's Sweet Dreams. And so on.

You can flick past nonsense like Blue Guitar (by two Moody Bluesmen) and Ozark Mountain Daredevils' vapid radio hit Jackie Blue.

So, utterly uneven as most compilations aiming for a genre are. But lots of oldies and forgotten gems to enjoy without ads for car sales yards and yelping radio jocks in between.

If you get my meaning.

Share It

Your Comments

Gavin Hancock - Dec 13, 2011

Fairplay G but licensing the original version of the title track probably would've blown the budget for the entire project and its sequels!

post a comment

More from this section   Music articles index

John Rowles: If I Only Had Time (Universal)

John Rowles: If I Only Had Time (Universal)

This unnecessarily expansive collection -- two discs, 53 songs and doubtless a tie-in to the autobiography -- confirms a few things about the big voiced singer. That he could really belt out... > Read more

The Golden Awesome: Autumn (M'Lady's)

The Golden Awesome: Autumn (M'Lady's)

Having been very impressed by the Amazing (although rather underwhelmed by Gold Medal Famous) I am a sucker for a band that doesn't under-sell itself on the naming front. Toad the Wet Sprocket... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

GUEST COMMENTATOR SIMON GRIGG on New Zealand's patchy history of political songs

GUEST COMMENTATOR SIMON GRIGG on New Zealand's patchy history of political songs

The story of political song in New Zealand is a mixed one. It goes from almost nothing to a flood to a trickle. For much of the history of popular song in New Zealand we simply did not make... > Read more

THE BARGAIN BUY: Lou Reed; Original Classic Album Series

THE BARGAIN BUY: Lou Reed; Original Classic Album Series

If there is any part of Lou Reed's long solo career which has been overlooked, it is collected in this bargain buy collection. The five albums here -- The Blue Mask, Legendary Hearts, Live in... > Read more