Bonnie Prince Billy: Is it the Sea? (BBC)

 |   |  1 min read

Bonnie Prince Billy: Wolf Among Wolves
Bonnie Prince Billy: Is it the Sea? (BBC)

Recorded live in Edinburgh before the release of his last album Lie Down in the Light (which as noted here was a slightly more upbeat if not uptempo outing for this prince of dark places) this is an exceptional release in the ever-expanding Billy (aka Will Oldham) canon.

With a small band of folk-locals Harem Scarem and guest voclaist Alex Neilson, Oldham reaches right back to some material from his earliest incarnation under the Palace moniker to the almost breezy Love Comes To Me from his 2006 album The Letting Go.

What impresses here is not simply the breadth of his songwriting - from old weird America to hints of Celtic folk, from murder ballads to suggestions of gospel - but the persuasiveness of his delivery while accompanied by fiddle, often hymnal sounding backing vocals and the most skeletal of acoustic guitar.

There is an almost ancient voice being conjured up which is timeless and intimate, and the large audience is hushed throughout.

Like Bob Dylan, Bruce Springsteen and (lesserly so) Neil Young, Oldham refashions older material to re-create them for himself and his audience, so this is not simply a "greatest hits" (ho ho ho, Oldham having a hit?) rendered live but songs being reoccupied and reconsidered.

Standouts are numerous but Wolf Among Wolves is utterly hypnotic as his voice cracks and creaks over wheezing accordion as he addresses pains of love and his weaknesses.

If Oldham/Billy/Palace etc is somehow only just coming on your radar then this would be a fine, if typically dark and demanding, place to start - although Lie Down in the Light might offer a few more rays of sunshine.

If Billy is already your man then this is one to confidently add to that burgeoning catalogue.

This is really quite something. 

 

Share It

Your Comments

post a comment

More from this section   Music articles index

Greg Fleming: Forget the Past (gregfleming.co.nz)

Greg Fleming: Forget the Past (gregfleming.co.nz)

In a guest column for Elsewhere this week, the New Zealand singer-songwriter Greg Fleming notes dryly that his last album Edge of the City with his band The Trains was his dark rock-noir album... > Read more

Moondoggies: Tidelands (Hardly Art)

Moondoggies: Tidelands (Hardly Art)

Their name might not inspire much confidence -- the sort of band name 12-year olds think up -- but this rootsy, alt.country and indie-rock outfit from Seattle on a SubPop imprint label have a... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

DON WALKER INTERVIEWED (2104): Cold Chisel, apples, pears and Engelbert

DON WALKER INTERVIEWED (2104): Cold Chisel, apples, pears and Engelbert

The droll, dry and fiercely intelligent Don Walker is consider by many to be among Australia's greatest songwriters -- if not the greatest – because of his songs for Cold Chisel, with the... > Read more

Otis Taylor: Otis Taylor's Contra Band (Telarc)

Otis Taylor: Otis Taylor's Contra Band (Telarc)

Singer-guitarist Taylor is nominally posted here under Blues in Elsewhere, but -- as always, see previous reviews here -- he doesn't easily fit into the prescription, broad though it might be.... > Read more