Neil Young: Greendale (Reprise)

 |   |  <1 min read

Neil Young: Bringin' Down Dinner
Neil Young: Greendale (Reprise)

Neil Young's Greendale confirms "quirky" and "eccentric" aren't always endearing qualities, especially on a song-cycle about three generations of a family which ... blah-blah.

With Crazy Horse he wades through the dreary narrative in the voices of the various characters (all sounding exactly like Neil Young) and piles on his musical cliches. 

The album is peppered with lazy writing: "When I was young people wore what they had on," is but one of the lyrical clunkers.

"Fair damsel", Neil?

There's a film and stage production apparently -- which the few who've seen say helps comprehension considerably -- but this, as an office wag noted, could be the first album to go straight to video. 


Share It

Your Comments

Gavin Hancock - Dec 13, 2011

One of my fave Neil Young albums since I acquired it in 2004. Listened from top to toe again the other night and I found that it's slipped down the leader board somewhat...many of the lyrics ane scenes are conspicuously bad. Oh well, that Crazy Horse backing can't be beat and Mr. Young is to be admired for such an epic concept (album/book/film/stage show/etc).

post a comment

More from this section   Music articles index

Whitey Morgan and the 78's: Born, Raised and Live from Flint (Bloodshot/Southbound)

Whitey Morgan and the 78's: Born, Raised and Live from Flint (Bloodshot/Southbound)

If there's any honkytonk, rockin' country cliche missed by this post-Waylon longhair wildman, it's probably only the one about the dog up'n'dyin'. With his hard rockin' band recorded live... > Read more

Various Artists: The History of Rhythm and Blues 1942-52 (Rhythmandbluesrecords/Southbound 4 CD Set)

Various Artists: The History of Rhythm and Blues 1942-52 (Rhythmandbluesrecords/Southbound 4 CD Set)

If the previous collection in this excellent series -- which went from country blues in the Twenties to swing, boogie and jump jive in the early Forties -- laid out the ground, this equally fine... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

Downliners Sect: The Sect (1964)

Downliners Sect: The Sect (1964)

Some people live interesting lives . . . but when it comes time to check out their timing is appalling: the author Aldous Huxley (Brave New World, The Doors of Perception) died the same day John F... > Read more

JOHN SCOFIELD INTERVIEWED: Has guitar, will travel . . . and travel, and travel

JOHN SCOFIELD INTERVIEWED: Has guitar, will travel . . . and travel, and travel

Looking back now it is hard to recall how it all started and who we should blame – but suddenly in the mid-70s there they were, electric guitarists spitting out notes faster than shells from... > Read more