Neil Young: Greendale (Reprise)

 |   |  <1 min read

Neil Young: Bringin' Down Dinner
Neil Young: Greendale (Reprise)

Neil Young's Greendale confirms "quirky" and "eccentric" aren't always endearing qualities, especially on a song-cycle about three generations of a family which ... blah-blah.

With Crazy Horse he wades through the dreary narrative in the voices of the various characters (all sounding exactly like Neil Young) and piles on his musical cliches. 

The album is peppered with lazy writing: "When I was young people wore what they had on," is but one of the lyrical clunkers.

"Fair damsel", Neil?

There's a film and stage production apparently -- which the few who've seen say helps comprehension considerably -- but this, as an office wag noted, could be the first album to go straight to video. 


Share It

Your Comments

Gavin Hancock - Dec 13, 2011

One of my fave Neil Young albums since I acquired it in 2004. Listened from top to toe again the other night and I found that it's slipped down the leader board somewhat...many of the lyrics ane scenes are conspicuously bad. Oh well, that Crazy Horse backing can't be beat and Mr. Young is to be admired for such an epic concept (album/book/film/stage show/etc).

post a comment

More from this section   Music articles index

Brian Wilson: No Pier Pressure (Universal)

Brian Wilson: No Pier Pressure (Universal)

As many senior Elsewhere readers or young scholars will know, Greil Marcus once famously opened his review of Bob Dylan's Self Portrait album with, "What is this shit?" So, eschewing... > Read more

Various Artists: Sweet Inspiration, The Songs of Dan Penn and Spooner Oldham (Ace)

Various Artists: Sweet Inspiration, The Songs of Dan Penn and Spooner Oldham (Ace)

Here's a long overdue collection, the songs of the Penn-Oldham songwriting team out of Alabama and Memphis whose songs were covered by the likes of Percy Sledge, Dionne Warwick, Charlie Rich, Etta... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

BLACK SATURDAY: NEW ZEALAND'S TRAGIC BLUNDERS IN SAMOA by MICHAEL FIELD REVIEWED (2006) Blood-stained history

BLACK SATURDAY: NEW ZEALAND'S TRAGIC BLUNDERS IN SAMOA by MICHAEL FIELD REVIEWED (2006) Blood-stained history

When Helen Clark offered an official government apology to the people of Samoa in 2002 it was easy to be cynical: there was an election looming (some 115,000 people in New Zealand identify... > Read more

WE NEED TO TALK ABOUT . . . Z'EV: He bangs the drum, and then some

WE NEED TO TALK ABOUT . . . Z'EV: He bangs the drum, and then some

When a couple of writers from the then-recently launched Re/Search tabloid went to visit the experimental percussionist known as Z'EV in 1981, the conversation was esoteric and philosophical.... > Read more