Neil Young: Greendale (Reprise)

 |   |  <1 min read

Neil Young: Bringin' Down Dinner
Neil Young: Greendale (Reprise)

Neil Young's Greendale confirms "quirky" and "eccentric" aren't always endearing qualities, especially on a song-cycle about three generations of a family which ... blah-blah.

With Crazy Horse he wades through the dreary narrative in the voices of the various characters (all sounding exactly like Neil Young) and piles on his musical cliches. 

The album is peppered with lazy writing: "When I was young people wore what they had on," is but one of the lyrical clunkers.

"Fair damsel", Neil?

There's a film and stage production apparently -- which the few who've seen say helps comprehension considerably -- but this, as an office wag noted, could be the first album to go straight to video. 


Share It

Your Comments

Gavin Hancock - Dec 13, 2011

One of my fave Neil Young albums since I acquired it in 2004. Listened from top to toe again the other night and I found that it's slipped down the leader board somewhat...many of the lyrics ane scenes are conspicuously bad. Oh well, that Crazy Horse backing can't be beat and Mr. Young is to be admired for such an epic concept (album/book/film/stage show/etc).

post a comment

More from this section   Music at Elsewhere articles index

Jimi Goodwin: Odludek (Heavenly)

Jimi Goodwin: Odludek (Heavenly)

Some years go when Mojo magazine picked 40 Cosmic Rock Albums – prog-rock in other words – there alongside the inevitable (Floyd, Yes, Genesis, King Crimson etc) were Radiohead, the... > Read more

Advance Base: A Shut-In's Prayer (Caldo Verde/Southbound)

Advance Base: A Shut-In's Prayer (Caldo Verde/Southbound)

With the economy of a poet Owen Ashworth, who is Advance Base, sketches in lonely lives reduced down to telling images and gives his characters names, and delivers his songs with spare arrangments... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

Dave Brubeck: Indian Summer (2007)

Dave Brubeck: Indian Summer (2007)

In 2007 when he was 86, the great pianist-composer Dave Brubeck was honoured as a Living Jazz Legend at the Kennedy Centre in Washington DC and received a standing ovation when he and Wynton... > Read more

THE BARGAIN BUY: The Beatles: A Hard Day's Night (DVD)

THE BARGAIN BUY: The Beatles: A Hard Day's Night (DVD)

What can you say about this classic, funny, cynical and joyous movie other than that every home should have a copy. It is the gateway DVD into the Beatles for most teenagers who might wonder... > Read more