The Dodos: Time to Die (Shock)

 |   |  1 min read

The Dodos: Time to Die
The Dodos: Time to Die (Shock)

As a number of overseas critics have noted, it isn’t entirely encouraging to hear singer Meric Long of this San Francisco duo announce repeatedly on Fables here, “I don’t wanna go in the fire, I just wanna stay in my home” on this, only the band’s third album. Not a man to be storming barricades at a guess despite the occasional anthemic effort here.

What hasn’t been noted however is just how much The Dodos, with their melodic pop and acoustic base, sound so much like Paul McCartney at his most comfortable and domesticated (McCartney, McCartney II and the more recent Chaos and Creation in the Backyard).

Being compared to one of pop’s greatest songsmiths is no bad thing, but The Dodos rarely rouse themselves any further than that and, despite complex song structures which can be annoyingly amorphous, this has to be counted a major disappointment after their breakthrough with the pop-folkadelic Visiter last year.

After that album there seemed the possibility they could have scaled the heights that the Violent Femmes, or more recently Fleet Foxes, managed. But despite the addition of vibes player Keaton Snyder to the core of Long and percussion player Logan Kroeber, this one falls far short of the “rock record” they said they wanted to make.

It isn’t without it charms (Troll Nacht which is Uncle Paul-cum-Fleet Foxes, the finger-pickin Acorn Factory) but, despite some edgy lyrics and the mildly menacing mood of the title track, over the long haul -- which feels very long around the mid-point -- this one sounds like they need to get out of the house and into the fire.

Share It

Your Comments

post a comment

More from this section   Music articles index

BEST OF ELSEWHERE 2011 Jonathan Besser: Campursari (Rattle)

BEST OF ELSEWHERE 2011 Jonathan Besser: Campursari (Rattle)

Since coming to New Zealand more than 30 years ago, the pianist-composer Jonathan Besser has enjoyed a highly successful and diverse career, first with violinist Chris Prosser in the Besser and... > Read more

Ramblin' Jack Elliott: A Stranger Here (Anti/Shock)

Ramblin' Jack Elliott: A Stranger Here (Anti/Shock)

When the previous album by this one-time fellow traveller with Woody Guthrie and mentor to the young Bob Dylan arrived -- I Stand Alone of two years back  -- I had to admit I thought Elliott... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

THE DEATH OF KLINGHOFFER: Opera on the frontline of history

THE DEATH OF KLINGHOFFER: Opera on the frontline of history

In the last quarter of the 20th century a new wave of opera emerged with stories which often seemed ripped from the headlines of contemporary newspapers. There were works about Richard Nixon... > Read more

Laura Riz: Gypsy Soul (Arc/Elite)

Laura Riz: Gypsy Soul (Arc/Elite)

Look, I have absoluely no doubt that singer Riz -- who was previously a fashion choreographer and director who sang light jazz and bossa nova -- makes music as authentically "Gypsy" as... > Read more