Patti Smith: Twelve

 |   |  <1 min read

Patti Smith: Twelve

Even in Smith's often unpredictable career this is unexpected: a covers album which includes Tears For Fears' Everybody Wants to Rule The World? Its very straight treatment is equally surprising.

You'd expect her to tear through it with righteous indignation but no, she delivers it as the bouncy pop ballad it always was.

But better is elsewhere: her drawling treatment of Hendrix' Are You Experienced? deftly interweaves snippets of other Hendrix lyrics (and guitarist Lenny Kaye peeling off bits of Stars That Play and other Hendrix riffs throughout); Neil Young's Helpless gets an appropriately world-weary reading; George Harrison's Within You Without You drones nicely over 12-string and hand drum; and Nirvana's Teen Spirit is eerily acoustic.

But mostly these are straight-ahead versions: the Stones' Gimme Shelter, Jefferson Airplane's White Rabbit, Dylan's Changing of the Guards, Paul Simon'sBoy in the Bubble.

Her band elevate most tracks but Smith's lack of invention or personal spin on the lyrics is disappointing.

There's a lingering feeling that if it weren't Smith you'd hardly continue paying attention. It's like an album of collected B-sides.

Share It

Your Comments

post a comment

More from this section   Music articles index

Gorillaz: Plastic Beach (EMI CD/DVD)

Gorillaz: Plastic Beach (EMI CD/DVD)

Gorillaz aren't the first to make "world music" of no fixed cultural abode (Elsewhere has noted 1 Giant Leap and the Laya Project among others) -- but there is something so diverse yet... > Read more

Thrashing Marlin: Donkey Deep (Braille)

Thrashing Marlin: Donkey Deep (Braille)

Four albums in a 15 year career seems a leisurely pace but David Donaldson and Steve Roche – the core of Wellington's Thrashing Marlin – are busy on other projects, as Donaldson... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

THE FAMOUS ELSEWHERE QUESTIONNAIRE: Iva Lamkum

THE FAMOUS ELSEWHERE QUESTIONNAIRE: Iva Lamkum

Elsewhere first came across Wellington singer-songwriter Iva Lamkum as far back as 2008 and said then of her self-titled debut EP, "if there is a more assured, musically intelligent and... > Read more

THE POINT by HARRY NILSSON (MVDvisual DVD through Southbound)

THE POINT by HARRY NILSSON (MVDvisual DVD through Southbound)

Despite the very best efforts and intentions of critics and writers -- Elsewhere among them -- the wayward genius of Harry Nilsson still goes past most people. His work has been occasionally... > Read more