James Yorkston: I was a Cat from a Book (Domino)

 |   |  <1 min read

James Yorkston: Just as Scared
James Yorkston: I was a Cat from a Book (Domino)

Much as I have enjoyed and admired a couple of previous albums by this Scottish folk singer, this album -- under the most fey title in living memory -- just strikes me as inane, precious, pretentiously understated, awkwardly and unpoetically phrased . . .

Just phenomenally dull in my hearing (and this from someone who actually liked the guy's previous stuff remember).

An album of such self-interested tediousness that it seems overseas reviewers closer to his home have struggled with it to the point of being unnaturally kind to a collection of badly constructed "songs" which is just awful and largely unlistenable.

Unless you are family.

I'm not.

And someone in the family should have slapped him hard on the forehead and said, "James . . .!"

Sort of "get a life/girlfriend" time for him I think.

Bye.

(For unintentional humour about this, check the clip below)

Share It

Your Comments

Jamie - Sep 16, 2012

So, ermm, just to clarify, you don't like it?

post a comment

More from this section   Music articles index

Maria Dallas: The Best of Maria Dallas (Sony)

Maria Dallas: The Best of Maria Dallas (Sony)

In 2013 – which was what we now know as “The Year of Our Lorde” – there was a huge upset at the Vodafone New Zealand Music Awards. For the young people in the... > Read more

David Dallas: Falling into Place (Dirty/Universal)

David Dallas: Falling into Place (Dirty/Universal)

In times to come when collections of contemporary New Zealand poetry are written (if not published in the form we have been used to), you'd like to think recent lyrics by Miriam Clancy, Moana... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

GUEST MUSICIAN PHIL WALSH tells of a band finally recording a single, four decades later

GUEST MUSICIAN PHIL WALSH tells of a band finally recording a single, four decades later

There wasn’t a lot to do for young teenagers in Morrinsville in the early Seventies. So Kim Murphy, Kevin Smith, another gal (Debbie) and I ended up forming our own little band. I think... > Read more

The MC5: The Big Bang! The Best of the MC5 (2000 compilation)

The MC5: The Big Bang! The Best of the MC5 (2000 compilation)

Writing against the tenor of these times, let it be said that sometimes there's no particular advantage in being first. Take Detroit's MC5. Essentially they made snotty, loud, politicised... > Read more