James Yorkston: I was a Cat from a Book (Domino)

 |   |  <1 min read

James Yorkston: Just as Scared
James Yorkston: I was a Cat from a Book (Domino)

Much as I have enjoyed and admired a couple of previous albums by this Scottish folk singer, this album -- under the most fey title in living memory -- just strikes me as inane, precious, pretentiously understated, awkwardly and unpoetically phrased . . .

Just phenomenally dull in my hearing (and this from someone who actually liked the guy's previous stuff remember).

An album of such self-interested tediousness that it seems overseas reviewers closer to his home have struggled with it to the point of being unnaturally kind to a collection of badly constructed "songs" which is just awful and largely unlistenable.

Unless you are family.

I'm not.

And someone in the family should have slapped him hard on the forehead and said, "James . . .!"

Sort of "get a life/girlfriend" time for him I think.

Bye.

(For unintentional humour about this, check the clip below)

Share It

Your Comments

Jamie - Sep 16, 2012

So, ermm, just to clarify, you don't like it?

post a comment

More from this section   Music articles index

Eric Lichter: ELKS in Paris (Diamond Market)

Eric Lichter: ELKS in Paris (Diamond Market)

Any New Zealander hearing the downbeat chorus-cum-hook of the opener on this album -- "how could a plan so beautiful go so pitifully bad" -- might think they have tuned in to a Greg... > Read more

Harry Manx and Kevin Breit: In Good We Trust (Stony Plain/Southbound)

Harry Manx and Kevin Breit: In Good We Trust (Stony Plain/Southbound)

These two guitarists are among the best in the wide country/alt.country/roots music arena. The evidence, should you doubt it, is all over this intimate and intelligent collection which opens with a... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

THE BARGAIN BUY: The Sony "Original Album Classics" series: Pop-pop pop music

THE BARGAIN BUY: The Sony "Original Album Classics" series: Pop-pop pop music

You can't help notice how cheap it is to get into popular music these days as record companies repackage and recycle albums in small and economic sets. The advantage of these budget-price... > Read more

THE POPE VOTE: Angels and Demons, black smoke, white smoke

THE POPE VOTE: Angels and Demons, black smoke, white smoke

Dan Brown's Vatican-based thriller Angels and Demons typically raises lots of questions: notably why would you buy the book now when you can just go see the movie? But to give Brown his due, he... > Read more