Various Artists: Country Soul Sisters (Soul Jazz/Southbound)

 |   |  1 min read

Jean Shepard: Two Whoops and a Holler
Various Artists: Country Soul Sisters (Soul Jazz/Southbound)

In a cover which bears no relevance to its contents and a 25-song decade-indifferent pastiche which roams freely between Jeannie C. Riley (the great Harper Valley PTA, of course), Lynn Anderson's white trash fantasy of Fancy (yeah, you wish!) and on to Patsy Cline's Ain't No Wheels on This Ship, this scattershot collection of assertive Southern women singers probably aims towards a feminist sensibility . . . but by being a collection of one-shots does the individual artists a disservice and perhaps implies a sisterhood which didn't exactly exist in the musical realm.

However, taken together, we see some broad themes emerge -- one being women can stand on their own, although maybe it helps to have  a man give them a leg up . . . although mostly the men are useless or necessary. But as a socio-political agenda this doesn't work.

Tammy Wynette's sensual welcome for an absent trucker-lover on Tonight My Baby's Coming Home hardly sits alongside its follow-up which is Jean Shepard's pre-feminist statement of self-determination on Satisfied Mind, let alone having Nancy Sinatra come in with her ruthlessly materialistically/acquisitive but also emotionally-destroyed sentiment of Get While The Gettin's Good.

Jeez, gals. Mixed messages or whuuut?

Many of these are very fine, important even, songs in their own right (actually very good if not great songs) but in this context it's like feminism, countrywomen neediness or assertion has been sprayed at a canvas like a Jackson Pollock painting.

Mashed together are social welfare daddies, women with a sexual ache for their distant lover, brutal male politics and beautiful feminist songs (the astonishing Southern Ferry Lane by Sammi Smith) which make very uncomfortable bedfellows.

So an incoherent collection . . . but what a fascinating compilation of dip'n'dive, sample'n'see songs.

Taste this with slow discretion and look for no over-arching agenda . . . and it will appear like a note left on the dining room table saying, "Honey-chile', I'm walking".

Or staying. 

Scattery, but a good 'un . . . Y'all.?

Share It

Your Comments

Mick C - Oct 29, 2012

Nice to hear the original again - there was a later version with inferior guitar licks!

post a comment

More from this section   Music articles index

Harper Simon: Harper Simon (Liberator)

Harper Simon: Harper Simon (Liberator)

Even on a blindfold test you'd probably only need the first few bars of the second song here -- after the traditional All to God -- to spot this is either Paul Simon, or someone very close to him.... > Read more

Girls Pissing on Girls Pissing: Scrying in Infirmary Architecture (Muzai)

Girls Pissing on Girls Pissing: Scrying in Infirmary Architecture (Muzai)

This charmingly named Auckland outfit got a few points in for their previous album Eeling which was rather demanding but showed some real flickers on 21st century post-punk declamatory... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

GUEST WRITER DON McGLASHAN on the power of songwriters in a cold climate

GUEST WRITER DON McGLASHAN on the power of songwriters in a cold climate

What follows is Don McGlashan's speech at the Apra Silver Scroll Award in Auckland on September 13, 2012. We print it here with Don's permission and it's our privilege to do so, as much for... > Read more

John and Jackie: Little Girl (1958)

John and Jackie: Little Girl (1958)

Simulated female orgasm on records isn't overly common, but there are certainly a few high profile examples. Counting back from Vanessa Daou's Zipless album (1994) and Donna Summer's Love to... > Read more