Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers: Hypnotic Eye (Warners)

 |   |  1 min read

Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers: Shadow People
Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers: Hypnotic Eye (Warners)

Most rock fans agree TP and his cracking Heartbreakers had a decade-long dream run after their self-titled debut in 76. Their taut Beatles/Byrds pop-rock welded to a nuggety rock'n'roll attitude and Petty's economic songs made their albums sound like collections of snappy singles. And when this Florida-native expanded into “Southern accents” (the title of their impressive sixth album) they seemed unstoppable.

But Petty prematurely aged by becoming a Traveling Wilbury, working with his heroes mostly a decade his senior. Petty's edge was smoothed off for country-rock and on subsequent TP/H albums, despite some successful singles, he often coasted across songs written as acoustic chugs.

Little in the past decade has possessed a vital spark (the 09 Live Anthology however showed what a great stadium band they could be) and the TP/H album Mojo four years ago was a shapeless affair.

This new one is being hailed as more hot-wired, but that's wishful thinking. When the band are given their head this sounds promising, especially on the passably brusque openers American Dream Plan B and Fault Lines (even if musically self-referential). And the politicised closer Shadow People has a low, mildly menacing funk-rock feel (somewhere between Lennon's I Want You and Petty's brooding songs from Southern Accents) which neatly reverts to moody minimalism at the midpoint of its six-plus minutes.

But between those bookends are some indifferent songs: All You Can Carry is studio-cum-stadium rock-by-numbers; Forgotten Man refers back to their debut but Petty is unconvincing despite the committed band; Sins of My Youth has an interesting sentiment (“I love you more than the sins of my youth”) but Petty makes it sound like a lesser George Harrison/Nelson Wilbury off-cut.

U Get Me High is a unmemorable. Power Drunk has a spook-voodoo swamp feel but – like Full Grown Boy which has a slithering jazzy attitude, guitarist Mike Campbell confirming on each he's the star player – both sound beamed in from other albums entirely. Petty connects with 60s Dylan in the surreal blues of Burnt Out Town though, but it's deja-heard.

So the patchy Hypnotic Eye isn't quite the return to form you might be reading about elsewhere.

But you'd always want to hear the Heartbreakers, a band which rarely fails to deliver.

Share It

Your Comments

Tom - Aug 4, 2014

'deja-heard'. brilliant.

Mick - Aug 5, 2014

May play a bit like eleven random songs thrown together but still the best Heartbreakers album since Damn The Torpedoes. Brilliant, don't hesitate.... GRAHAM REPLIES. Agreed, a great Heartbreakers album, it's actually Tom who let's it down in my opinion.

post a comment

More from this section   Music articles index

Whirimako Black/Richard Nunns: Te More (Rattle)

Whirimako Black/Richard Nunns: Te More (Rattle)

This gentle, hypnotic and spiritual album seems a natural consequence of all that has gone before from these two artists: Whirimako Black's moving songs in te reo (especially her exceptional Kura... > Read more

Myele Manzanza: OnePointOne (First Word)

Myele Manzanza: OnePointOne (First Word)

Knowing only that drummer Manzanza was formerly in New Zealand's electronica-soul outfit Electric Wire Hustle doesn't prepare you for this vigorous and out-there second album under his own name.... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

EILEN JEWELL INTERVIEWED (2016): Bringing it all back home

EILEN JEWELL INTERVIEWED (2016): Bringing it all back home

There's no category for Eilen Jewell's music: Some will call it country and some alt.country, but there is also a clear European jazz quality in many songs, she acknowledges Billie Holliday and... > Read more

San Francisco to Sacramento: The road less travelled

San Francisco to Sacramento: The road less travelled

Bill Foster never saw an animal he didn't like. And like so much that he'd shoot it, have it's head chopped off and stuffed, and brought back to his bar in smalltown Rio Vista, halfway between San... > Read more