Jeff Buckley: You and I (Sony)

 |   |  <1 min read

Jeff Buckley: You and I  (Sony)

Although he only released two EPs (the excellent Live at Sin-E and the lesser Live From the Bataclan) and the Grace album in his lifetime, the small catalogue of Jeff Buckley – who drowned in May 97 – has considerably inflated with posthumous live releases, expanded editions and such, which are uneven and mostly songs never intended for release.

These 10 songs – drawn for about 40 available – are lifted from casual pre-Grace studio workouts while producer Steve Addabbo, on behalf of Columbia who'd signed Buckley, tried to figure out what the singer was capable of.

Diversity if nothing else, because here are versions of songs by Dylan (an overwrought Just Like a Woman), Sly Stone (Everyday People), the Smiths (nice treatment of Boy With a Thorn in His Side, and I Know It's Over), Led Zeppelin (their unexceptional Night Flight) and Bukka White (Poor Boy Long Way From Home).

There's an urgent run-through of Grace (only for those interested in how a song can be formed from raw clay) and the unfinished Dream of You And I – which will later become You And I on the posthumous Sketches for My Sweetheart The Drunk – which is barely a song at all.

Although nothing diminishes Buckley's reputation, nothing here – other than confirming his encyclopedic musical knowledge – enhances it either.

It is what it is, a talented guy in a studio trying to find a direction.

Of marginal interest . . . at best.

Share It

Your Comments

post a comment

More from this section   Music articles index

BEST OF ELSEWHERE 2010 Roky Erickson with Okkervil River: True Love Cast Out All Evil (Unspk)

BEST OF ELSEWHERE 2010 Roky Erickson with Okkervil River: True Love Cast Out All Evil (Unspk)

The most recent album by the emotionally damaged Daniel Johnston, Is and Always Was, found his often fragile and shaky acoustic pop placed in the context of a band -- and while it was fine to hear... > Read more

The Dodos: Time to Die (Shock)

The Dodos: Time to Die (Shock)

As a number of overseas critics have noted, it isn’t entirely encouraging to hear singer Meric Long of this San Francisco duo announce repeatedly on Fables here, “I don’t wanna go... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

PAUL McCARTNEY'S OFFICIAL BIOGRAPHY REVIEWED (1997): Still can't buy the love?

PAUL McCARTNEY'S OFFICIAL BIOGRAPHY REVIEWED (1997): Still can't buy the love?

Paul McCartney is the Beatle old fans love to hate: his sins are manifest in Silly Love Songs, a Linda and not a Yoko, the permanent Mr Thumbs Aloft attitude, the knighthood which his old colleague... > Read more

The Who: My Generation

The Who: My Generation

In a classic cover -- bassist John Entwistle sporting the famous Pop Art-referencing "Union Jacket" -- the Who's debut album of '65 captured the youthful energy, anger, self-doubt and... > Read more