Roger Waters: Is This Really the Life We Want? (Sony)

 |   |  1 min read

Picture That
Roger Waters: Is This Really the Life We Want? (Sony)

Elsewhere is of the unwavering opinion that most of Roger Waters' recorded output and ideas – most notably Pink Floyd's The Wall, a demandingly bleak and pretentious concept album – are more an endurance test or aural torture than they are insightful music.

Yes, we know that The Wall is HUGE and popular, and knowing that we try sometimes to have another go at it, but to no avail.

Waters remains the arch pessimist if not professional miserablist here on yet another concept album for these awful days of refugee children drowned in the Med, the failure of the Gods we created and so on.

Oh, and of course Mr Trump. And again some parental issues and sort of God Complex stuff.

There are terrible things out there in the world these days but to say you find this album a grim journey doesn't mean you are unsympathetic to the plight of the oppressed or don't get the complexities of this dysfunctional world.

It just means that these frequently tuneless, often familiar sounding songs – all those descending minor chords and stentorian, declamatory lyrics – are tedious, portentously grim and a struggle to get through.

Even the song Smell the Roses comes off as all Animals-era doom (“there's nothing but screams in the field of dreams”) and so on. In Waters' misanthropic worldview the roses are poisoned, if not poison.

The politics may be right on if pretty damn obvious, but as an album this one's gravitas is propped up by orchestration, samples from radio and sweeping effects. And by about halfway through you feel you are being lectured to once more by Waters who seems so locked into his own moroseness and superiority as a commentator that he can't hear how damnably dull this is.

A blunt instrument can inflict a lot of damage, but it is always just a blunt instrument.

And this album is certainly that.

Share It

Your Comments

post a comment

More from this section   Music articles index

Wilco: Ashes of American Flags (Warners DVD)

Wilco: Ashes of American Flags (Warners DVD)

Part way through this insightful, beautifully shot mix of live concert footage and Wilco on the road, mainman Jeff Tweedy notes how he loves representational art and music in that the music... > Read more

Paul McCartney: NEW (Universal)

Paul McCartney: NEW (Universal)

After his previous pop-rock album Memory Almost Full six years ago which included songs that seemed to be farewells or self-penned eulogies (“On the day that I die I'd like bells to be... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

THE BARGAIN BUY: Tom Lehrer; An Evening Wasted with Tom Lehrer

THE BARGAIN BUY: Tom Lehrer; An Evening Wasted with Tom Lehrer

In one of the university courses I take, I spend a couple of hours on a lecture under the title -- lifted from Frank Zappa -- "Does Humour Belong in Music?" The general point is that... > Read more

ORNETTE COLEMAN, DAVE BRUBECK AND ME: A Song For Guy

ORNETTE COLEMAN, DAVE BRUBECK AND ME: A Song For Guy

Ronnie Wickens was one of the last to leave my 50th birthday party at Portside. As I made for the door I looked back, and there he was at the bar chatting to -- maybe even chatting up -- a couple... > Read more