The Chieftains featuring Ry Cooder: San Patricio (Universal)

 |   |  1 min read

The Chieftains with Ry Cooder: A La Orilla de un Palmar (with Linda Ronstadt)
The Chieftains featuring Ry Cooder: San Patricio (Universal)

Here's something we don't hear as often as we used to: a concept album with guest stars and telling a historical story – in this case the Irish Catholics migrant soldiers who deserted from the predominantly Protestant US army during the Mexican-American war and sided with the Mexicans.


The San Patricio Battalion actually contained a multi-cultural crew but Paddy Moloney of the Chieftains centres on the Irish experience – which means pipes and fiddles alongside mostly Mexican music, and that makes for an oddly forced concept. The story, such as it is, doesn't appear until halfway through when Ry Cooder delivers the lovely, weary ballad The Sands of Mexico, Liam Neeson narrates March to Battle and Moya Brennan sings the Lullaby for the Dead.


Before and after that it is mostly folkloric Mexican music with guests Lila Downs (the cantina jig La Iguana) and Linda Ronstadt (the melancholy A La Orilla de Un Palmar with Molony on intrusive tin whistle), and songs which exist independent of the narrative.


In many ways this is as much Cooder's project – it is a well-traveled path for him and his acoustic introduction to Cancion Mixteca is lovely. But while you can't deny the joy of songs like El Chivo (Los Cenzontles' party-time with fiddles) and El Relampago, or the aching sound of Carlos Nunez's Galacian bagpipes and Chavela Vargas' tear-filled Luz de Luna, over the long haul this doesn't hang together convincingly as a concept or musical marriage.

Share It

Your Comments

post a comment

More from this section   World Music articles index

ELSEWHERE'S FAMOUS WOMAD QUESTIONNAIRE: Nicky Bomba of the Melbourne Ska Orcheatra (Aust)

ELSEWHERE'S FAMOUS WOMAD QUESTIONNAIRE: Nicky Bomba of the Melbourne Ska Orcheatra (Aust)

The goodtime sound of ska got a whole lot stranger when the Melbourne Ska Orchestra formed after a one-off event in 2003. The idea was to get a world-record number of horn players together in St... > Read more

BEST OF ELSEWHERE 2008 Omara Portuondo: Gracias (Harmonia Mundi)

BEST OF ELSEWHERE 2008 Omara Portuondo: Gracias (Harmonia Mundi)

The great Cuban singer - who came to world attention via the Buena Vista Social Club a decade ago - is still going even though she is in her late 70, which may be some kind of testament to the... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

THE FAMOUS ELSEWHERE SONGWRITER QUESTIONNAIRE: Steve Abel

THE FAMOUS ELSEWHERE SONGWRITER QUESTIONNAIRE: Steve Abel

Singer-songwriter Steve Abel is extremely well-known and highly regarded by fellow New Zealand musicians and a loyal following, but perhaps completely unrecognised beyond that world. That he... > Read more

GUEST WRITER DON McGLASHAN on the power of songwriters in a cold climate

GUEST WRITER DON McGLASHAN on the power of songwriters in a cold climate

What follows is Don McGlashan's speech at the Apra Silver Scroll Award in Auckland on September 13, 2012. We print it here with Don's permission and it's our privilege to do so, as much for... > Read more