BLACK SATURDAY: NEW ZEALAND'S TRAGIC BLUNDERS IN SAMOA by MICHAEL FIELD REVIEWED (2006) Blood-stained history

 |   |  2 min read

BLACK SATURDAY: NEW ZEALAND'S TRAGIC BLUNDERS IN SAMOA by MICHAEL FIELD REVIEWED (2006) Blood-stained history

When Helen Clark offered an official government apology to the people of Samoa in 2002 it was easy to be cynical: there was an election looming (some 115,000 people in New Zealand identify themselves as Samoan), and it came around the same time as she offered apologies to the gay and Chinese communities for historic wrongs.

Yet -- as this detailed and compelling account by one of the Pacific’s foremost commentators makes clear -- New Zealand’s early contact with Samoa was often shamefully racist, sometimes woefully wrong-headed and frequently unforgivably repressive, even within the different mores of the period.

The apology was necessary, particularly for the events which lead to the 1918 influenza epidemic which wiped out 22 per cent of the Samoan population (in New Zealand only 0.5 percent died), and the shootings on Black Saturday -- December 28 1929 -- in which a peaceful march of unarmed pro-independence demonstrators was fired on.

Field doesn’t resile from attributing personal blame for the violence and repression inflicted on the Mau independence movement, or from noting that even the current official account appears to diminish the Mau movement and refers to the crowd on Black Saturday as a “mob”. 

The bulk of Field’s 200-page book is taken up with a consideration of the suppression of the Mau movement -- which was predominantly pacifist in nature and scrupulously polite by inclination -- by a series of ineffectual, patronising New Zealand governors.

But Field also offers a useful potted history of the early colonial period; the scramble between Germany, the United States and Britain to claim the islands; the uneasy relationship Europeans and Samoans sometimes had with the Chinese community; and -- albeit briefly -- relations between New Zealand and Samoa since independence in 1963.

His account of how the influenza epidemic occurred through the arrival of the vessel Talune (which was allowed to dock in Apia by New Zealand authorities who could not have been unaware of the consequences) is heartbreaking: a chief died in Apia and a boat came from his village to collect the body, all 17 rowers died; a young girl slept between her ailing parents and woke to find them both dead; 80 students in a dormitory lay ill as the New Zealand administrator outside berated them for their laziness and shouted, “I should like to see them all in Hell!” 

A hallmark of the New Zealand administrators was paternalism combined with racism, and the belief that any moves towards independence could be suppressed by force.

Colonel Robert Tate (governor 1919-23) said the democratic nature of New Zealand troops towards Samoans fed the “notion that they [Samoans] were as good as the white man”, and his replacement General George Richardson (1923-28) incited fears in New Zealand about a violent Mau rebellion. Colonel Stephen Allen’s brief but bloody period ( May 1928 - April 1931) is shameful.

Field’s research draws on a persuasive collection of private letters, court documents, newspaper accounts and personal knowledge (he spent many years in Samoa), and it makes for very uncomfortable but essential reading.

That apology was long overdue.

Share It

Your Comments

post a comment

More from this section   Writing articles index

THE MONTY PYTHON AUTOBIOGRAPHY by THE PYTHONS(2003)

THE MONTY PYTHON AUTOBIOGRAPHY by THE PYTHONS(2003)

The shadow of the Beatles is cast long over Monty Python's Flying Circus. The late George Harrison always said he felt something of the band's spirit passed to Monty Python, which appeared on... > Read more

AMY WINEHOUSE: THE BIOGRAPHY 1983-2011 by CHAS NEWKEY-BURDEN

AMY WINEHOUSE: THE BIOGRAPHY 1983-2011 by CHAS NEWKEY-BURDEN

As with many of my acquaintance, when I heard of Amy Winehouse's death it was with mixed emotions: a gloomy sense of the inevitability of it, sadness and then anger. That weird anger we reserve for... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

Drive-By Truckers: Brighter than Creation's Dark (2008)

Drive-By Truckers: Brighter than Creation's Dark (2008)

Now more than two decades into their impressive career -- and with more than two dozen live and studio albums behind them -- the Drive-By Truckers out of Athens in Georgia  inspire passionate... > Read more

WIRE, ON THE RECORD (1977-80): The short, sharp pop of art-punk

WIRE, ON THE RECORD (1977-80): The short, sharp pop of art-punk

The best thing about the punk years wasn’t punk of course. That stuff exhausted itself pretty fast. No, punk’s importance was the doors that it opened to let in the likes of the... > Read more