THE BEST AUSTRALIAN SCIENCE WRITING, 2011 edited by STEPHEN PINCOCK

 |   |  2 min read

THE BEST AUSTRALIAN SCIENCE WRITING, 2011 edited by STEPHEN PINCOCK

Science is a problem for mainstream media. It isn't sexy, usually can't be reduced to a snappy headline or soundbite, progress is glacially slow in a fast-turnaround world, there are too many big words, and its practitioners are often more at home in the lab than blinking into the light of the public domain.

Science takes its time. Darwin didn't exactly bolt into print with his world-changing On the Origin of Species and whatever cure there is for cancer is arriving in incrementally slow steps.

Pity the poor journalist – two days at best to get the story – coming to a significant scientific development which involves decades of prior research, complex language and a front-person ill at ease with the media.

Scientists themselves frequently find it difficult to tailor their explanations and ideas in a way which successfully communicates. There are exceptions of course. In print the late Stephen Jay Gould and Simon Singh, charmers like polymath Simon Schama, and on television Dr Robert Winston, although the closest physics may get to small-screen time is the geek sit-com The Big Bang Theory.

But science struggles on every front to get whatever message it has out there, which may explain why this anthology of almost 30 essays by some sassy Australian writers is only the first such collection. Yet here is wit aplenty and clear communication.

Richard Hughes hyperventilates about Deepak Chopra's quasi-mystical psychobabble when it intrudes into his world of maths and physics (“Holy meaningless blather, Batman!” he explodes after quoting some Chopra nonsense) and there is a tidy little piece explaining why stars twinkle. (They don't.)

Germaine Greer has a sharp and gently poetic piece on Australia's east coast floods (“Why were we so surprised?”); Tim Flannery comes over cosmic about carbon, our atmosphere and “Gaia's housekeeping”; and there are insightful articles on sound, string theory (for Big Bang Theory viewers) and Lousy science (Christine Kenneally on head lice).

Cleverly at the end of each essay – some are no more than a couple of pages – there are teaser links to other articles. However they are amusing: The pointer after the twinkling stars is to “Twinkle in father's eye” and leads you to Deborah Smith's article about saving the black rhino from extinction through artificial insemination, and also “stars” which takes you not to astronomy but the Rolling Stones and an essay on how music (specifically being in band) helps evolutionary biology (you get to meet more girls and sleep with them).

As Robyn Williams observes here in an essay under the title Science without a capital S: Battling Grumpy Uncles, Media Tarts and Jurassic Marxists, “Science is one of the few human constructs designed to test its own veracity continuously. There is no point in time in which we all nod, wise men with beards, women with six-figure IQs, and say 'That's settled . . . next!' All aspects of scientific enquiry are always under review.”

True, but so annoying in a world which requires certainties.

The crux of Williams' essay is the counter-science folk (climate change deniers in his case) who demand equal time but immediately avoid “science” in favour of democracy and “discussion”.

Scientists, it seems can't win.

But in this collection they do. Not unequivocally (some are a little dogged), but here is mostly pointed, humorous, informative and clear writing about that media orphan called “science”.

Share It

Your Comments

post a comment

More from this section   Writing articles index

THE BOB DYLAN ENCYCLOPEDIA by MICHAEL GRAY: More song and dance

THE BOB DYLAN ENCYCLOPEDIA by MICHAEL GRAY: More song and dance

Writer Michael Gray is not backward about coming forward: he includes an entry on himself in this massive tome published in 2006 which is alternately illuminating, absurdly amusing, opinionated or... > Read more

FROM EARTH'S END; THE BEST OF NEW ZEALAND COMICS by ADRIAN KINNAIRD

FROM EARTH'S END; THE BEST OF NEW ZEALAND COMICS by ADRIAN KINNAIRD

There's the old observation that for most people history began with the first thing they remember, like in Billy Joel's song We Didn't Start the Fire which is just a baby-boomer litany of names and... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

Gomez: Five Men in a Hut (EMI)

Gomez: Five Men in a Hut (EMI)

No one reviewed this double disc when it came out late last year which is not surprising: although this British band picked up the coveted Mercury Award for their 1998 debut Bring It On they seem... > Read more

UB40: Just another labour of love

UB40: Just another labour of love

It was a few years ago now, but UB40 were back for another New Zealand tour. Well pardon my lack of enthusiasm. It's not that, like most critics, I don't have much time for their MOR reggae. I... > Read more