WINGS: RED ROSE SPEEDWAY, CONSIDERED (2018): The malaise or just lazy?

 |   |  3 min read

Loup (First Indian on the Moon)
WINGS: RED ROSE SPEEDWAY, CONSIDERED (2018): The malaise or just lazy?

For every person who loves Paul McCartney's Mull of Kintyre there is another who couldn't hate it more. For everyone who loves With a Little Luck there is me.

McCartney's most popular songs seem to divide people: he could write beautiful love songs . . . and Silly Love Songs.

A curious case in point is My Love which appeared on his Red Rose Speedway album. Some people find it sentimental tripe, and there is a good case to be made for that.

Then there is me.

The song's melody and warm arrangement for electric piano seem effortless, the guitar part by new Wings member Henry McCullough (formerly of Spooky Tooth and Joe Cocker's Grease Band) and the Mellotron “strings” compliment each other, and the song's four minutes pass too quickly.

It was the undoubted highpoint of Red Rose Speedway, and album which was shapeless and for the most part very lightweight. The irony being that the lightest moment – My Love – was so beautifully crafted that it rose above everything else.

Red Rose Speedway has been remastered and reissued in the on-going Paul McCartney Archive Collection (through Universal in New Zealand) and was released simultaneously with its predecessor Wild Life, Wings' debut album.

McCartney's original intention was that RRS be a double album but the economies of the day meant it was chopped to a single and among what was lost were songs by Denny Laine and McCullough.

This was McCartney's band and the original producer Glyn Johns quit after a few weeks so McCartney took the helm.

(It would not be until At the Speed of Sound that McCartney allowed an appearance of democracy by having songs from the loyal Denny Laine, Joe English and Jimmy McCulloch.)

712ZX5xUJQL._SL1500_The expanded editions of RRS now allow us to get a clearer impression of what it might have sounded like as a double, and Laine's polite pop on I Would Only Smile would have been an asset in the company of McCartney's weaker moments (One More Kiss is a real make-weight).

What was of interest on the original album was the more experimental pieces like the bent instrumental Loup (First Indian on the Moon) which might have been as a result of the intake of marijuana at the time, and the final segue of songs Hold Me Tight/Lazy Dynamite/Hands of Love/Power Cut where he tried to replicate the pastiche of half-finished songs at the end of Abbey Road. The difference was Abbey Road had Lennon's bits'n'pieces and this one just sagged under the weight of so much Macca cottonwool..

The album was very limp and received a critical drubbing from most quarters although did well on the charts because McCartney's name still had some cachet. A few writers acclaimed for its very MOR vacuousness which was refreshing when most other artists were getting dark, deep and loud.

But even McCartney rejected it in later years.

For what it's worth the expanded edition includes Mary Had a Little Lamb, his excellent rocker Hi Hi Hi, live versions of The Mess and Best Friend (which confirm the band was tight enough), Live and Let Die which had been recorded around the same time, the catchy C Moon, Linda's reggae-lite Seaside Woman and their soft-lights treatment of the Fifties ballad Tragedy.

And more, most of it of little consequence.

Red Rose Speedway – in a fine gatefold sleeve with art by Eduardo Paolozzi and live photos of Wings etc – is far from an essential McCartney/Wings album.

But what came next – when two members of the band quit just before a planned recording session in Lagos – changed everything and out of adversity McCartney returned with the album which confirmed he was once again a frontline contender.

That album was Band on the Run.


61OM_USFs_L._SL1200_For a consideration of Wings' Wild Life reissue go here and for more on Paul McCartney's lengthy career start here.


The remastered Red Rose Speedway comes in multiple iterations: Special Edition 2-CD; the original nine-track album on the first disc, include previously unreleased recordings and non-album singles on a second; Deluxe Edition 3-CD/2-DVD/1-Blu-Ray; the original album on the first disc, original "double" album on a second disc; previously unreleased recordings and non-album singles on a three disc and the DVD includes music videos, the "James Paul McCartney" TV show, "Live And Let Die" in Liverpool and The Bruce McMouse Show with 5.1 format, as well as on Blu-Ray.

    There is also the remastered vinyl double album version which includes special edition versions as well as a link to download materials.

    Elsewhere occasionally revisits albums -- classics sometimes, but more often oddities or overlooked albums by major artists -- and you can find a number of them starting here

Share It

Your Comments

Graham - Dec 17, 2018

Always preferred "The Mess" to "My Love" when singles were a thing...

Rick - Dec 21, 2018

Enough goddam Beatles!

post a comment

More from this section   The Album Considered articles index

TONTON MACOUTE: THEIR SELF-TITLED DEBUT, CONSIDERED (1971): The jazz-rock classical connection

TONTON MACOUTE: THEIR SELF-TITLED DEBUT, CONSIDERED (1971): The jazz-rock classical connection

It's likely the most familiar name on the 1971 debut album by British jazz-rockers Tonton Macoute isn't that of any band member or even engineer Martin Rushent (who went on to produce the... > Read more

PETER GREEN: IN THE SKIES and LITTLE DREAMER, CONSIDERED (1979/1980): The slight return in the late Seventies

PETER GREEN: IN THE SKIES and LITTLE DREAMER, CONSIDERED (1979/1980): The slight return in the late Seventies

The sad story of Sixties singer-guitarist and songwriter Peter Green (born Peter Greenbaum in 1946, of Bethnal Green) probably needs little repeating but the bare facts look like this.... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

IVAN NEVILLE INTERVIEWED (2005): The family that plays together . . .

IVAN NEVILLE INTERVIEWED (2005): The family that plays together . . .

More than four decades after one of the family first scored a hit, and 25 years from the first Neville Brothers album Fiyo on the Bayou, you could almost forgive the brothers Aaron, Art, Charles... > Read more

GUEST PHOTOGRAPHER PAUL DALY offers images from his award-winning travel portfolio

GUEST PHOTOGRAPHER PAUL DALY offers images from his award-winning travel portfolio

Last week Christchurch-based photographer Paul Daly of Nomadic Planet won the Cathay Pacific Travel Photographer of the Year award at the annual New Zealand TravCom awards for travel writers and... > Read more