The Hollies: If I Needed Someone (1965)

 |   |  1 min read

The Hollies: If I Needed Someone (1965)

As we know the Beatles were great borrowers, stealers and adapters. From old rock'n'roll (Run For Your Life, I'm Down) to current Dylan (You've Got to Hide Your Love Away, Norwegian Wood) and Northern soul (Got to Get You Into My Life) they would listen, take an influence and reshape it in their own image.

When you listen to the first version of Rain it was a pure slice of Searchers jangle pop . . . but slowed to half speed and with Lennon's lyrics, and a backward section it became something else. It became a Beatles' classic . . .  on a B-side.

 

When people first heard George Harrison's If I Needed Someone on Rubber Soul there would be few who didn't think, “Hmmm, the Hollies?”

Certainly the Hollies thought so and, having heard the acetate, happily covered it.

Regrettably for them it failed to make the top reaches of the British charts as their previous songs had.

It appeared on the same day as Rubber Soul was released.

The general public weren't the only ones unmoved by it, Harrison hated the Hollies' version and dismissed it publicly as “rubbish” and sneered that it “sounds like session men who've just got together in the studio without ever seeing each other before”.

Ouch.

And that was a slight the Hollies' singer Graham Nash never forgot and blamed Harrison for the single's lack of success.

In 2013 Nash – who had left the Hollies a few years after that song – was still smarting: “Pardon me if you don't like our fucking record, but keep it to yourself, if you please.”

.

For more one-offs, oddities or songs with an interesting backstory see From the Vaults


Share It

Your Comments

Peggy in America - Dec 18, 2023

I love these roots n' offshoots; music ... aaah! The Universal Language. Put me in mine of a tune by Dawes, "If I Needed Someone," møre of late, but - diff vein. They're all arteries that lead back to the heart. Merry Holidays, Mistah Graham! -- Keep rockin'.

post a comment

More from this section   From the Vaults articles index

Flesh D-Vice: Legend of Lugosi (1989)

Flesh D-Vice: Legend of Lugosi (1989)

This is just here for those of us old enough -- and perhaps dumb enough -- to remember the sheer visceral power and life-threatening live shows that this band (from Palmerston North? I will stand... > Read more

Nina Simone: Alone Again, Naturally (1982)

Nina Simone: Alone Again, Naturally (1982)

Lord knows, Gilbert O'Sullivan's 1972 hit Alone Again, Naturally was one of the more depressing songs ever to top the charts around the world. Although the tune sounded almost jaunty the opening... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

INFORM-EDUCATE-ENTERTAIN; THE DVD by PUBLIC SERVICE BROADCASTING  (Test Card/Southbound DVD)

INFORM-EDUCATE-ENTERTAIN; THE DVD by PUBLIC SERVICE BROADCASTING (Test Card/Southbound DVD)

Those many of us who considered Public Service Broadcastings' Inform-Educate-Entertain to be one of the best albums of 2013 definitely need this DVD, because -- as we know -- PSB are as much about... > Read more

WE NEED TO TALK ABOUT . . . TEX WITHERS: Country'n'Western from the East End

WE NEED TO TALK ABOUT . . . TEX WITHERS: Country'n'Western from the East End

The more you try to find out about Tex Withers, the more confusing it can become. One thing everyone agrees on however is that this country music singer in London – who insisted he had... > Read more