Bob Dylan:Belle Isle (1970)

 |   |  1 min read

Bob Dylan:Belle Isle (1970)

Because of the length and breadth of his catalogue, it is hardly surprising Bob Dylan should have appeared at From the Vaults from time to time (see here), not always with great, lost songs either.

A few are real duds. 

His myth-destroying Self Portrait double album of 1970 is one of those oddities you can return to and find the oddball rubbing shoulders with the truly awful and the ocassional sublime song.

This piece is among the latter and although Dylan took the writing credit it is clear from the first line that it is based closely on a traditional Celtic ballad.

It is an interesting song in that it is a dialogue and Dylan plays the roles with genuine feeling, and the supportive string and vocal arrangement is equally sensitive. Taken together they evoke a Romantic poet on a ramble through the Lake District or the lochs of Scotland.

But there is also something more. Both the lyrics and the strings suggest something darker going on, the male character is a watcher who declares his secret love in the final verse . . . and the fair maiden gets nothing to say about this.

There is an enduring mystery about the song even as the last notes fade.

One of Dylan's finest deliveries of the period, unusual in that it was enhanced by strings and a traditional song which sounds timeless.

Alongside Copper Kettle -- also a traditional song with strings (American, and one he didn't claim to write) -- this is one of those songs which almost redeems Self Portrait. 


For more oddities, one-offs or songs with an interesting backstory use the RSS feed for daily updates, and check the massive back-catalogue at From the Vaults.


Share It

Your Comments

Music of Bob Dylan - Aug 14, 2020

We are actively promoting a link to this interesting topic on The Bob Dylan Project at:

If you are interested, we are a portal to all the great information related to this topic.

Join us inside Bob Dylan Music Box.

post a comment

More from this section   From the Vaults articles index

Lou Reed: Families (1979)

Lou Reed: Families (1979)

Lou Reed probably never struck you as having a sentimental streak, but this song (from his album The Bells) is as nakedly autobiographical and pained as John Lennon's Mother. It is the... > Read more

Brix E. Smith and Nigel Kennedy: Hurdy Gurdy Man (1991)

Brix E. Smith and Nigel Kennedy: Hurdy Gurdy Man (1991)

Tribute albums can be dodgy: some are fun, and the more obscure the artists the better they get. But you are wise to avoid the Joy Division tribute A Means to an End which features those household... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

VICTORIA KELLY, INTERVIEWED (2022): Poetry, Prince and meditations on death

VICTORIA KELLY, INTERVIEWED (2022): Poetry, Prince and meditations on death

No matter what you say about Victoria Kelly she is always bigger and more important than words can convey. She is a composer, producer and singer certainly, but that hardly scratches the surface.... > Read more

MARILYN MANSON INTERVIEWED (1999): The spook circus, cont'd

MARILYN MANSON INTERVIEWED (1999): The spook circus, cont'd

The curious thing about Marilyn Manson isn't the pancake makeup, the alarming contact lenses or even the cover of his latest album, Mechanical Animals, where he's some kind of naked androgynous... > Read more