Jonathan Bree: The Primrose Path (Lil' Chief)

 |   |  2 min read

Jonathan Bree: Seven
Jonathan Bree: The Primrose Path (Lil' Chief)

If we think of "album" in the more traditonal sense of the word -- a collection of photos, memorabilia etc - then this quiet and remarkably honest album by Jonathan Bree (formerly one half of the Brunettes with Heather Mansfield) certainly qualitfies.

This is not just the post-breakup record with all the self-centredness and slightly misanthropic tone which often comes with that, but it also addresses other matters, notably on the final song Boxes in which Bree looks at all their Lil' Chief CDs "that no one wants to buy, stacked in my car", old love letters from yesterday's girl and the mix-tapes returned which constituted the relationship . . . and what might have been ("major label backing, but that's another song").

There's a weariness about that closer, but before then he's already tired of the casual booty call sex (the slow and sober opener with its barely-there but up-close vocal); he attempts unsuccessfully to stand outside himself ("when she says it's over . . . you'll hurt, you'll cry") on the Eraserhead- eerie Beat Your Head; shapes himself as the poet of doomed romanticism (Bored at the Mall) and admits "there should should be a better way to play this hurting game, when you're feeling like a fake and you both just masturbate . . ." (on Seven, which then weeps into the gorgeously sad "once I had a girl, as precious as a pearl").

And we aren't even at the mid-point of these economical but densely packed and emotional 35 minutes.

Loss and the wounds of love have rarely been so nakedly revealed -- or utilised we should also say -- and nor that uncomfortable truth when there's a possible relationship . . . but the new one isn't going to measure up to the absent love . . . because that says more about the protagonist than this other woman.

This can be -- and in some places will be if you've ever been through this -- very uncomfortable listening. But what ameliorates it are the simple arrangements which refer to McCartney pop-romanticism (Duckie's Lament), simple synth-pop and the customary Brunettes musical tropes of glockenspiel, distant strings etc.

And perhaps also that in the title track it seems Mr Bree has come out of his narcissism long enough to find another relationship . . . although she must listen to these songs and wonder, "What might you say about me if this ends?"

On the following song she is in bed with a laptop and a cat and he . . .  

Towards the closing overs of the Brunettes -- as on Paper Dolls of 2009 -- their twee factor was wound up far too high (something the Lil' Chief label didn't exactly have a radar for, witness the Gladeyes' cuter-than-thou) but you won't make that observation here.

This is utterly self-centred and the more courageous for it. Everything is material for songwriters, especially when they at their most vulnerable, self-obsessed and perhaps even emotionally manipulative. 

But you can't imagine as he tours anyone's going to bay for these songs or whoop like chimps when he says, "And this off the new album, it's called . . . Crippled Darling".

Yes, it's "an album" . . . and in two decades time if things such as secondhand CD and vinyl stores exist (this is on both) someone will stumble upon this, look at the cover and think . . .

Like the sound of this? Then check out the Tokey Tones and Princess Chelsea.

Share It

Your Comments

post a comment

More from this section   Music at Elsewhere articles index

Methyl Ethel: Triage (4AD)

Methyl Ethel: Triage (4AD)

Their location (Perth in Western Australia) and the band name (which brings to mind Nick Cave/Grinderman's raucous Depth Charge Ethyl) might conjure up some pretty brittle and aggressive.... > Read more

Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds, Dig Lazarus Dig (Mute)

Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds, Dig Lazarus Dig (Mute)

My guess is that by this time in his career (and your life) you are either for Cave or couldn't care less. If you are with him but have your critical radar alert you might not concur with the... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

THE BARGAIN BUY: The Young Rascals; Original Album Series

THE BARGAIN BUY: The Young Rascals; Original Album Series

If New Jersey's Young Rascals had done nothing more than release their exceptional Good Lovin' -- one of the most urgent, addictive and thrilling singles of 1966 -- they would still be imprinted in... > Read more

THE BARGAIN BUY: Various Artists; Western Swing, The Absolutely Essential 3CD Collection

THE BARGAIN BUY: Various Artists; Western Swing, The Absolutely Essential 3CD Collection

Although the title of this collection might seem to oversell itself, and these 60 songs come with no liner notes, you set all that aside because of the consistent quality of the content and the... > Read more