Alt-J: This is All Yours (Infectious)

 |   |  <1 min read

Alt-J: Warm Foothills
Alt-J: This is All Yours (Infectious)

Much as I liked the debut album by this British outfit An Awesome Wave and said they seemed likely to be the Next Indie.Cult Thing to go bigger, I certainly had reservations about seeing them live.

Their music was so studio-crafted and often inward looking that I couldn't see how it would translate live. Well, I saw them and although I concede others liked them much better than I did , but I felt my reservations were right.

They are clever, and this album is more such refined cleverness . . . but it rarely has any traction or adhesiveness. It is one of those "Hmm that's nice" (the delicate Arrival in Nara/Nara) but "That's annoyingly oddball" (the silly aren't-we-quirky punkabilly stomp of Left hand Free) albums of separate parts.

Let's not go there on the lyrics either: "I'm gonna bed into you like a cat beds into a beanbag, turn you inside out and lick you like a crisp packet". That's from Every Other Freckle which borrows it's "Hey!" punctuations from the Lumineers.

The Gospel of John Hurt ("chest bursts like John Hurt") is a strange but beguiling piece. 

There's a flute interpolation apropos of not much at all, Warm Foothills has a choral opening and a nicely weaving vocal line (and whistling) and the final 16 minute piece Leaving Nara makes me think this Mercury Prize-winning outfit is now The Band Most LIkely to Go Prog-folk.

Very patchy indeed. 

Share It

Your Comments

post a comment

More from this section   Music at Elsewhere articles index

The Lemon Twigs: Everything Harmony (Captured Tracks/digital outlets)

The Lemon Twigs: Everything Harmony (Captured Tracks/digital outlets)

To be frank, on the basis of two of their three previous albums we have heard, we've been seriously underwhelmed by the fashionable and hip Lemon Twigs, two gifted New York brothers who do have a... > Read more

Lucy Dacus: Forever is a Feeling (digital outlets)

Lucy Dacus: Forever is a Feeling (digital outlets)

When bands break up it's interesting to observe which members go on to the most success: in 1970 would anyone have put their money on George Harrison over McCartney and Lennon? The Stones never... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

YET MORE PROVOCATIONS OF RATTLES (2023): From art music to thanks-but-no-thanks

YET MORE PROVOCATIONS OF RATTLES (2023): From art music to thanks-but-no-thanks

As we have noted in previous Provocation/Provocations of Rattles columns, the Auckland label releases albums at such a rate it is often impossible to keep up. And so here, as in the past, we... > Read more

FINALISTS, PACIFIC MUSIC AWARDS (2022): And the winner is . . .

FINALISTS, PACIFIC MUSIC AWARDS (2022): And the winner is . . .

It's that time again when the Pacific artists are honoured and here follows the list of nominees. The awards -- having had to be online the past two years -- are scheduled now for August 4. More... > Read more