THE CLASH, COMBAT ROCK + THE PEOPLE'S HALL (2022): Band on the stagger

 |   |  1 min read

THE CLASH, COMBAT ROCK + THE PEOPLE'S HALL (2022): Band on the stagger
Although there was a subsequent album – the awful Cut the Crap – Combat Rock in 1982 was the last Clash album anyone could take seriously.

Which isn't to say it's any good.

It arrived in a nondescript cover almost free of meaning, aside from the band members looking in different directions, and while the title resonated with their militant stance it could also have referred to the group pulling itself apart.

Guitarist/writer and co-founder Mick Jones had wanted a double album but – after their London Calling (a double) and Sandinista! (a triple) – the record company, and worse his bandmates, refused him.

Jones and singer/writer and guitarist Joe Strummer had been at loggerheads for some time about the band's direction. Heroin-addicted drummer Topper Headon was shoved out even before Combat Rock was released.

Combat Rock – with bassist Paul Simonon – was the final album of the classic line-up and, despite the tensions, stood as an uneven but economic Clash album which sprung two hits, Rock the Casbah and Jones' Should I Stay Or Should I Go which might have been about his off-on girlfriend Ellen Foley (who sang back-up on tuneless Car Jamming) or Jones' question about whether he was still wanted in the band.

He got his answer soon enough, 14 months later after a volatile American tour he was fired by Strummer, Simonon and Clash manager Bernie Rhodes.

On its 40thanniversary Combat Rock gets reissued with People's Hall, an extra disc of outtakes and rarities from the same period.

The best Combat tracks – Rock the Casbah, Should I Stay, Straight to Hell – show a band still capable of greatness but elsewhere there are lesser returns. Mostly because Strummer decided he was a better spoken-word barker-cum-orator than a singer.

He was wrong.

The opener Know Your Rights is a declamatory rant (“you have the right not to be killed”), the lo-range funk Red Angel Dragnet with spoken word passages by Paul Simonon lifted from Taxi Driver is little better and former Beat poet Allen Ginsberg reads some dire rhyming couplets on Ghetto Defendant which might have been better remaining as a reggae instrumental which underpins it.

The People's Hall tracks place context around Combat Rock but with the exception of their hip-hop influenced This is Radio Clash and the jazzy Fulham Connection little here is essential Clash: Futura 2000 features rap from the graffiti artist of that name who appeared on Combat's serviceable Overpowered by Funk (it can charitably described as “old school”), there are jams and retread reggae, and no one needs the four minute-plus audio-verite opener of people waiting outside a Clash concert.

Combat Rock found a dysfunctional band wading through punk, rock, hip-hop and reggae influences and the 24 track expanded reissue -- which could be whittled into a decent single album – invites no major reconsideration.

But it was better than the Crap that followed.

Share It

Your Comments

post a comment

More from this section   Absolute Elsewhere articles index

CLIMIE FISHER INTERVIEWED (1988): Studio changes everything

CLIMIE FISHER INTERVIEWED (1988): Studio changes everything

The rock music thing used to be quite straightforward. A few people got together, practiced a few covers, wrote some original material and the band honed its act in pubs and clubs and on the... > Read more

NEIL DIAMOND CONSIDERED (2014): Back down the melody road

NEIL DIAMOND CONSIDERED (2014): Back down the melody road

Speak this low: Neil Diamond used to be cool. Not tacky cool like Engelbert Humperdinck, but actual rock star cool. Quite when he lost the cool is hard to say, but you'd have to factor in... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

THE FAMOUS ELSEWHERE QUESTIONNAIRE: Li'l Chuck

THE FAMOUS ELSEWHERE QUESTIONNAIRE: Li'l Chuck

Christchurch-based Li'l Chuck – aka David Thorpe – is the self-styled “One Man Skiffle Machine” whose latest album was appropriately recorded in mono in Sugar Ray's Vintage... > Read more

Elsewhere Art . . . studio boffins

Elsewhere Art . . . studio boffins

Sometime in the very late Eighties I spent a day in an Auckland studio with a very well known dance-pop band. It was one of the dullest days imaginable. They had recorded their instrumental... > Read more