BOB DYLAN; ON LOVE AND LOST OPPORTUNITY (2020): If you see her say more than hello

 |   |  2 min read

BOB DYLAN; ON LOVE AND LOST OPPORTUNITY (2020): If you see her say more than hello

As a new decade dawns even Bob Dylan's most loyal fans must sense that they might not be hearing any new music from their man.

His last album of original songs was more than nine years ago and since then he has delivered three albums of covers -- Shadows in the Night, Fallen Angels and the triple CD/vinyl set Triplicate. Many of these were songs associated with Frank Sinatra (not Strangers in the Night or My Way, but more obscure Sinatra songs) and written in the Forties and Fifties.

He has arranged them  -- beautifully -- for his band which includes pedal steel guitar. So there is not a cocktail piano in earshot.

Bob_Dylan___Shadows_in_the_NightWhy would he do those songs?

Because hasn't Bob Dylan -- despite the title of DA Pennebaker's film -- always looked back?

As a young man he looked to old country, blues and folk, after the motorcycle accident he refreshed himself again on old songs, he threw country and pop covers onto the Self Portrait hodge-podge collection, went once more to the wells for the albums Good As I Been to You and World Gone Wrong . . .

Dylan replenished himself often by looking back. We can only hope that is what he has been doing with these last three albums.

But when he sings the classic ballads on those albums they often come with a world weary, hard-won wisdom of age . . . as in the case Some Enchanted Evening by Rodgers and Hammerstein from the Fifties musical South Pacific.

It's a song which is most often given a chest-swelling treatment by big voiced balladeers. As in these instances. 

Some Enchanted Evening, by Harry Connick Jnr

Some Enchanted Evening, by Alfie Boe

But Dylan, a man who placed pre-eminence on lyrics (like Sinatra) really found the key to that song which boasts a beautiful melody so tempting for the balladeers.

The key comes at the end.

It is in the lines where he sings about finding that rare love and never letting her go, because if you do you might spend the rest of your life alone. That is where the sadness and emotional weight of the lyric lies and Dylan -- almost in his mid 70s when he sang it -- brought a lifetime of regret, lost loves, experience and gravitas to those words.

Given he knew that song from his youth -- it was so enormously popular it was inescapable, even in the Sixties -- it's no surprise you can easily locate a song of his own with a not dissimilar sentiment.

The recent box set Travelin' Thru 1967-1969, The Bootleg Series Vol 15 which collected his songs from the John Wesley Harding, Nashville Skyline and Johnny Cash rehearsals and television show allowed us to hear again a song from that period when he was turning down the volume and driving deeper into lyrics with emotional resonance.

I_Threw_It_All_Away_single_coverIt is not too far a stretch from the idea of lost opportunity in Some Enchanted Evening to that on his own I Threw It All Away which appeared on Nashville Skyline.

It hardly matters these days -- half a century later -- who the Dylan lyric was about. It stands as a song of regret and lost opportunity.

You'd love to hear him sing it again now, bringing that cracked and broken voice of experience to a lyric like this which so deserves the regret he could bring.

Here's his first take as heard on the Travelin' Through box set.


And here's the released version from Nashville Skyline

I Threw It All Away

Share It

Your Comments

post a comment

More from this section   Absolute articles index

ELVIS COSTELLO INTERVIEWED (1991): Every thorn has a rose

ELVIS COSTELLO INTERVIEWED (1991): Every thorn has a rose

Elvis Costello has lurked about under any number of names in the past decade or so. He’s been Howard Coward of the Coward Brother (when he sang with T-Bone Burnett), Napoleon Dynamite (for... > Read more



In her long career Kate Bush has only rarely performed live, which is odd when you think how she established herself as a theatrical performer who had studied dance and movement. But after a... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

Gladys Knight: Talent with talons

Gladys Knight: Talent with talons

Press conferences are a waste of time and no sensible journalist entertains them. Ask your best question and everyone else gets the great answer. And if you are a print journalist those lazy... > Read more

GUEST WRITER SARAH JANE ROWLAND explores a Hollywood treatment of mental illness

GUEST WRITER SARAH JANE ROWLAND explores a Hollywood treatment of mental illness

Much of the hoopla surrounding Anatole Litvak’s 1948 drama The Snake Pit focused on the treatment of its subject matter. It was one of Hollywood’s first attempts to tackle... > Read more