Brix E. Smith and Nigel Kennedy: Hurdy Gurdy Man (1991)

 |   |  1 min read

Brix E. Smith and Nigel Kennedy: Hurdy Gurdy Man (1991)

Tribute albums can be dodgy: some are fun, and the more obscure the artists the better they get. But you are wise to avoid the Joy Division tribute A Means to an End which features those household names Honeymoon Stitch, Girls Against Boys, Starchildren and godheadSILO.

Or any of those to Tom Waits.

But how can you resist an album of Donovan songs sung by the likes of bands with names such as when People Were Shorter And Lived Near The Water, Papa Sprain & Butterfly Child or Hypnolovewheel?

As with most tribute albums however it broke down into some great/some unmemorable/some gawdawful.

Donovan himself introduced this collection (in a self-referential whisper of almost Donovan-parody mystico-babble). A benediction, no doubt.

For every duffer though (the Posies‘ shoegazing River Song) there's was goodie (the hilarious skyscraper monochrome Colours by Superconductor).

The ghost of Jesus and Mary Chain overtook Hypnolovewheel's treatment of the trippy Epistle to Dippy, but Spirit of the West took themselves far too seriously on Sunshine Superman. (C’mon, guys, save yourselves for the U2 tribute, huh?)

The really great stuff came from Windwalker on a monstrously angry, eight-minute version of The Fat Angel (they sound deserving of the Fillmore in '67), and Papa Sprain & Butterfly Child’s offering a skeletal dancefloor, new-cool jazz version of Lalena.

Hurdy Gurdy Man by Smith and Kennedy was the breathtaking opener with Nigel playing astonishing Hendrix/ Clapton/Cream raga-rock on electric violin - a real threat. 

Kennedy should have tossed over the crap quasi-jazz he was doing at this time and got serious about rock violin. He kept threatening an album in tribute to Hendrix, and on the evidence of this we lived in hope.

Then he did it.

Hmmm. Tribute albums, huh?


For more oddities, one-offs or songs with an interesting backstory use the RSS feed for daily updates, and check the massive back-catalogue at From the Vaults.

Share It

Your Comments

Samuel - Aug 24, 2010


Lots of info on Papa Sprain here:

http://bubblegumcage3.com/2009/10/01/post-rocktoberfest-2009-the-delightfully-confusing-world-of-papa-sprain/

And here's an MP3 of "Lalena":

http://bubblegumcage3.files.wordpress.com/2010/02/07-lalena.mp3

I'm seriously considering starting a religion with Brix Smith as the messiah. Well, not seriously but...

Elsie Stockdale - Sep 3, 2010

Don't give up on Nigel Kennedy ! Listen to his latyest album, Shhh ! He's getting there !

post a comment

More from this section   From the Vaults articles index

Paul McCartney: Check My Machine (1980)

Paul McCartney: Check My Machine (1980)

In the Seventies Paul McCartney enjoyed a remarkable revival of fortunes -- at the start of the decade the Beatles broke up, he released a couple of feet-finding solo albums, got the band Wings... > Read more

Mamie Van Doren: Separate the Men From the Boys (1958)

Mamie Van Doren: Separate the Men From the Boys (1958)

Mamie Van Doren's not inconsiderable assets -- big breasts, bleached blonde hair and a breathy speaking style -- served her well for a career in cinema and self-promotion when she emerged as a kind... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

WE NEED TO TALK ABOUT . . . THE MAMAS AND THE PAPAS: Trip, stumble and fall

WE NEED TO TALK ABOUT . . . THE MAMAS AND THE PAPAS: Trip, stumble and fall

When we look at the cast of misfits, murderers and murder victims, oddballs and eccentrics in our articles at WE NEED TO TALK ABOUT, you'd be entitled to ask why Rock and Roll Hall of Famers and... > Read more

GUEST WRITER CHRIS CREE BROWN on Tony Palmer's film about the life and music of Benjamin Britten

GUEST WRITER CHRIS CREE BROWN on Tony Palmer's film about the life and music of Benjamin Britten

There's a wonderfully poignant tale about Benjamin Britten and (Sir) Michael Tippett. Britten, along with his long-time companion and inspiration Peter Pears, were both British pacifists and... > Read more