Field Music: Plumb (Shock)

Field Music: Is This the Picture?
Field Music: Plumb (Shock)

Having been spectacularly underwhelmed by the much acclaimed previous albums by this British band doesn't mean I don't come to another hoping for the best.

But the best here has always be the property of their predecssors and it would only be the most short-concentration span -- or 15-year old -- reviewer who didn't start ticking off the accumulation of source material (Beatles and Beach Boys in '66, XTC's literate pop, sub-Prince funk given the Anglo-spin, job lots of prog from Genesis among others).

When they aim for "fun" they come off well short of properly outre acts like MGMT, Empire of the Sun and early Of Montreal. Oh, and Choosing Sides is Led Zepp rendered like a very gay edition (and perhaps allegedy ironic) of Split Enz, all fey surface no substance.

And it speaks volumes very little here can sustain itself beyond the few-minute mark.

I think it enormously awful, boring (even in its short bits), pretentious and self-satisfied.

I predict it will be much favoured by others.

The posted audio track here starts Beatles 65 + Enz + MGMT + . . .

Oh, you get the picture.

What plonkers.

Looking for something similar but actually a whole lot better? You could do worse than start . . . anywhere else I guess, but start with the intralinks.

Your Comments

nathan graves - Mar 21, 2012

Saw these guys ( 2 brothers in the band) swop, interplay and have a great time last year at the Scala in London. Great choice as always.

post a comment

More from this section

Dion: Tank Full of Blues (Blue Horizon)

Dion: Tank Full of Blues (Blue Horizon)

Dion's first hits – the classics Runaround Sue and The Wanderer – came before the Beatles even got into a British recording studio and by then, in his early 20s, he'd already been... > Read more

The Eastern: Hope and Wire (Rough Peel Records/Rhythmethod)

The Eastern: Hope and Wire (Rough Peel Records/Rhythmethod)

The self-titled 09 debut and Arrows ('10) by this Christchurch band alerted many to their poetic, political and bare-knuckle country-influenced songs which sit alongside Springsteen's working... > Read more

New Elsewhere

JAMES BURTON INTERVIEWED (2014): Six stringer for the stars

JAMES BURTON INTERVIEWED (2014): Six stringer for the stars

A conversation with legendary guitarist James Burton could almost sound like name-dropping: he's worked with not one but two Elvises, Ray Charles, Joni Mitchell, Jerry Lee Lewis, George... > Read more

PLEASE PLEASE ME; THE POTENCY OF MUSIC (an essay, 2014)

PLEASE PLEASE ME; THE POTENCY OF MUSIC (an essay, 2014)

About eight months ago I was invited to write a chapter in a very academic book entitled Soundscapes of Well Being in Popular Music. It was being edited by – among others – Professor... > Read more