THE BEST OF ELSEWHERE 2019: THE READERS' CHOICES

 |   |  6 min read

THE BEST OF ELSEWHERE 2019: THE READERS' CHOICES
Following Elsewhere posting its choices for the Best of the Year albums and The Best in Reissues (of what we heard, obviously a lot went past us) we invited Elsewhere readers to tell us what they were impressed by this year.

Here is what people told us . . . and where Elsewhere had reviewed the album we have highlighted it with a link to our original review. (Some people's choices were also in our Best Of lists)

Thanks to everyone who made the time, you have given us all some suggestions for holiday season listening.

Here is what people said (and some mentioned best concerts too). Looks like I've got some catchin' up to do.


Greg says

Orville Peck - hi lonesome homo erotic desert motel ballads

David Kilgour & The Heavy Eights - Bobbie's a Girl devastatingly beautiful and spare soundtracks from one of our greatest musical adventurers 

Moon Duo - Stars are the Light- everything cool and sumptuous that has defined them with an added focus on poptastic grooving


Pedro the Swift

tells us that his favourite albums for the year seem mostly the same as everyone else’s judging by the end of year lists I’ve seen so far, but the following three records seem to have been missed by most and are on high rotation on my stereo:
Drift Code - Rustin Man: Fronted by ex Talk Talk bass player Paul Webb this is the long awaited follow up to early naughties Out Of Season. Meticulously recorded he sounds not unlike Robert Wyatt on this gem of an album. (And a sad RIP to ex TT band mate Mark Hollis)
Jimmy Lee - Raphael Saadiq: gritty neo-soul from one time Tony! Toni! Tone! legend 
You Made It This Far - Esther Rose: Lovely country album from this US singer conjuring up the spirit of Patsy Cline in these songs of hard truths and reminisces.
And my reissue of the year goes to...
Emperor Tomato Ketchup -Stereolab: I have no idea why I missed them first time around but their entire back catalogue is going through a reissue program so they’re all ripe for reappraisal. This one is a real standout closely followed by Mars Audio Quintec.
AND with the end of the decade fast approaching is it too early to note that we’re only a couple of years away from the 60th Anniversary of the release of The Beatles debut record and beginning of another cycle of reissues!


Blair considers

he thought the year a bit underwhelming but found these 10

On the Line - Jenny Lewis - echoes of Lennon/Spector early 70's - basic piano driven core with wearied lyrics & vocals . Outstanding!

Guesswork - Lloyd Cole - one of the most boring live shows (and an equally faceless guitarist), but a great, great songwriter and this had inventive synth lines to  boot.

No Other - Gene Clark - reissue of the year . Based on this alone he outstrips all the other Byrds that ever existed - McGuinn, Crosby, Parsons , Hillman etc

Abbey Road - The Beatles - what's this doing here? no comment required - the tail end of the holy grail of recorded popular music.

The Flood in Colour - Joe Pug - I'm hearing early, relevant Joe Henry/T Bone Burnett and that isn't a bad thing

Saint of Lost Causes- Justin Townes Earle - intense solo show during the year matched by an angry largely blues driven set of songs, a chip off the old block indeed.

Sunset Kids - Jesse Malin - worth it for Room 13 co-write with Lucinda Williams

Heavenly - Cigarettes After Sex - more of the same - Mazzy Star meets Chris Isaak meets the Church equals great guitar lines , marks off for disturbing fetish lyrics (again!)

Fury & Redemption - Sturgill Simpson - this guy is a star , simple as that

Tales of America - J.S Ondara - is this the Tracy Chapman debut of this century? - whatever  it's really good


Glenn tells us

Elbow - Best of Elbow: Yes, technically came out late 2018 but I didn't see it here until new year.  A very good double album of their large back catalogue.

Marlon Williams - Live at Auckland Town Hall. I had to get this after seeing him at Villa Maria and being blown away but the purity and power of his voice.  The Town Hall recording isn't sonically great but you still feel like you're there.

Teskey Brothers - Run Home Slow. Leaving the best to  last.  A superb follow-up to their first album.  World-class musicianship, vocals, songwriting.  I've recommended them to heaps of people who'd never heard of them and everyone come back saying they love them.  Their gig at the PowerStation was a great way to finish up the year - stunning.  How cool is it when you are a soul/blues band and can pull off a cover of War Pigs and make it perfectly fit the set!



Jo gets in with

Pick of your list for me are Tiny Ruins and Julia Jacklin; many repeat plays in our house.  The other three on high rotate have been:

One Piece at a Time by Finn Andrews – just blissful listening, gorgeous ballads to sing along to and the wonderfully disturbing “One By The Venom”!

Driving Music by Mallrat – rising popstar from Brisbane – “Charlie” is especially delightful.

Open Hearts by Tommy and the Fallen Horses – alt-country Kiwi music from the heart (especially evident when seeing the band live)

And if I may slip an album from 2018 – Out Of The Oddness by the quirky Whangarei-born and Lisbon, Portugal-based Tom Lee Richards (experimental electronic, pop, roots) who I think deserves way more exposure.

Nick says

Agree with quite a few of your selections for the best of for 2019 BUT inexplicably you left out the Black Pumas self titled debut - on high rotate for many weeks in our household!



Lee believes in

David Kilgour and the Heavy Eights – Bobbie’s a Girl. Laid back songs ideal for a sunny Sunday afternoon, it doesn’t get any better than this.

Sulfate – Sulfate. Listen to in a dark room at substantial volume

The National – I Am Easy To Find. A beautiful album aided by guest vocalists which brings a fresh feel to their sound.  

Hard to leave out Aldous Harding – Designer, JJ Cale – Stay Around, and The Beat – Public Confidential, out of my list also


Haden says

they asked around the office and they came up with these (and more)

Wilco “Ode to Joy” - takes 4 or 5 listens to ease into- clever arrangement in writing , wonderful Tweedy croon at strength , masterful instrument playing from all members-it’s a truly fluid relaxed sound - watch their recent shows on YouTube-Nels Cline is staggering-my staff say its “dad” indie country but I don’t necessarily agree.

Bon Iver “ ii era”-masterful arrangement and technique of his defiant uncommercial sound- it’s not “For Emma, Forever Ago” and I suspect you’re not going to sing along to any songs off it at a concert  but that’s not the point…. the world has moved on and so has he. Very much looking forward to seeing him live next year.

Orville Peck “Pony”- his voice holds you, smart, unexpected palate of drifter style lyrics-they say he’s a possible incarnation of Elvis-maybe that’s so as he sounds perfect and timeless.

The Delines “ The Imperial” – very subtle and quite but embraces you tightly with very cleaver lyrics and relaxing instrumentations- released in early Jan I reckon as others do that it’s been criminally overlooked due to its early 2019 release but I guess NZ isn’t really a perfect fit for mid-American Angst Alt Country

Sleater-Kinney “The Centre Won’t Hold”  - reinvented – it’s an album that doesn’t feel comfortable like there past but I don’t think that’s the point with it-it’s a spiky confrontational platform for future works and it works

Bill Callahan “Shepherd in a Sheepskin vest” smooth drifting vivid intelligent lyrics and guitar melody…perfect

NZ BEST goes to Kool Aid “Family Portrait EP”- its cleaver catchy writing…Low Fi good everywhere and possibly a Christchurch thing that no one else will really get – which makes it more the better-hopefully the world won’t catch onto them-only 22 monthly listeners on Spotify and they cant be wrong!

New album we thought we wouldn’t tap our toes to during 2019 BUT have is…Harley Poe “ Have a Great Life …they call them Folk-that may be a compliment.

Best Reissue of 2019…The Blue Nile “Walk Across the Rooftops” in vinyl and more epic for that.

Best NZ Single - “I Want to Live like a Golden Retriever” by Edward Gains

thanks to all of you . . . . and feel free to Post a Comment

hare krishmas to y'all! 

Share It

Your Comments

Chris P - Dec 18, 2019

Late to the party, but one album off the top of my head: Tomeka Reid - Old New: https://cuneiformrecords.bandcamp.com/album/old-new

post a comment

More from this section   Absolute articles index

THE BEE GEES INTERVIEWED (1999). Inside Hitsville FLA

THE BEE GEES INTERVIEWED (1999). Inside Hitsville FLA

South Beach in Miami where tanned, bodies beautiful in stamp-sized bikinis parade the boardwalk, the sky is permablue and as you lie in the warm ocean watching the sun set over pastel Art Deco... > Read more

THE BAND'S LAST WALTZ REISSUED (2016): Another twirl on the dancefloor

THE BAND'S LAST WALTZ REISSUED (2016): Another twirl on the dancefloor

When The Band decided to call it a day in 1976 they did it in style. Not just any group could call in Martin Scorsese to film their farewell concert at the Winterland in San Francisco, or have... > Read more

Elsewhere at Elsewhere

THE BARGAIN BUY: The Sony "Original Album Classics" series: Funk soul brothers (and sisters)

THE BARGAIN BUY: The Sony "Original Album Classics" series: Funk soul brothers (and sisters)

In a previous Bargain Buy column we bemoaned that the great Isley Brothers had been unfairly overlooked by rock's history writers. I guess that's because most of those scribes are white and tend to... > Read more

EPs by Shani.O

EPs by Shani.O

With so many CDs commanding and demanding attention Elsewhere will run this occasional column by the informed and opinionated Shani.O. She will scoop up some of those many EP releases, in... > Read more